Giant Souls in Dark Souls II: New Game Plus
In Dark Souls II, the Giant Souls you collect are key items that persist into New Game Plus, and their primary function remains the same: each one reduces the defense of the final boss, Nashandra, by a significant amount. You keep all Giant Souls you obtained in your first playthrough when you start New Game Plus, but you must collect them again in the new cycle if you want the full damage bonus against her.
What Giant Souls Do
Giant Souls are special key items dropped by the Giant Lord, the Ancient Dragon, and found on the corpses of the Giant’s Kinship and the Dragon Memory. Their only mechanical effect in the game is to weaken Nashandra: each Giant Soul in your possession reduces her physical and elemental defenses by a percentage. With all five Giant Souls, her defenses are reduced by 80% compared to having none. This makes the final fight dramatically easier, especially at higher New Game cycles where her health and damage scale up.
How New Game Plus Affects Your Inventory
When you begin New Game Plus in Dark Souls II, you retain all key items from your previous playthrough, including Giant Souls, boss souls, and the Lordvessel-equivalent items. However, the game does not track which Giant Souls you have “used” — they are not consumed on use. So the five you collected in your first playthrough are still in your inventory when you start the next cycle. This means you will immediately have the damage reduction against Nashandra, even before re-collecting any new ones.
Do You Need to Collect Them Again?
No, you do not need to collect them again for the Nashandra fight. Since they persist, you already have the full effect. However, if you want the achievement for collecting all five in a single playthrough, you will need to grab them again in the new cycle, because achievements are tied to the current playthrough’s progress. Also, if you are playing the Scholar of the First Sin edition, the Giant Souls are still required to access the optional boss Aldia, but that requirement is based on having the souls in your inventory, not on a per-cycle basis.
Common Misconception: Do Giant Souls Carry Over?
Many players mistakenly believe that Giant Souls are consumed when you fight Nashandra, or that they reset on New Game Plus. Neither is true. They are permanent key items. The only thing that resets is the world state: enemies, items, and bosses respawn, but your inventory persists. So the souls you have are the souls you keep. The confusion often arises because other consumable souls (like Boss Souls) are used for weapons or spells, but Giant Souls have no other use.
How to Get All Five Giant Souls
If you need to collect them again for the achievement or just want to be thorough, here are the locations:
- Giant Lord’s Soul – Dropped by the Giant Lord boss in the Memory of Jeigh, accessed after defeating the Looking Glass Knight.
- Ancient Dragon Soul – Dropped by the Ancient Dragon boss in the Dragon Shrine.
- Giant’s Kinship – Found in the Memory of the King, after defeating the Giant Lord. This is the one that allows you to access the Throne of Want.
- Giant Soul (from the Dragon Memory) – Found in the Dragon Memory, which is accessed by using the Ashen Mist Heart on the giant corpse in the Forest of Fallen Giants.
- Giant Soul (from the Giant Lord’s Memory) – Also in the Memory of Jeigh, on a corpse near the Giant Lord’s arena.
Note: The Giant’s Kinship is not a “Giant Soul” in the same sense, but it is counted as one for the defense reduction. So you need all five of these items to get the full 80% reduction.
Do Giant Souls Affect Other Bosses?
No, Giant Souls only affect Nashandra. They do not weaken any other boss, including the DLC bosses or the optional boss Aldia. Aldia is only affected by the presence of the Giant’s Kinship, which allows you to fight him after Nashandra if you have met certain conditions (like defeating Vendrick). But the defense reduction is exclusive to Nashandra.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: Can I drop or sell Giant Souls?
No, they are key items and cannot be dropped or sold. They stay in your inventory permanently.
Q: Do Giant Souls increase damage against Nashandra in NG+?
Yes, the effect is the same in every New Game cycle. The percentage reduction is constant, but Nashandra’s health and damage scale up, so the relative impact is similar.
Q: Is it worth collecting all five before fighting Nashandra?
Yes, if you want an easier fight. Without any Giant Souls, Nashandra has high defenses, and the fight can be long and punishing. With all five, she takes significantly more damage, making the fight much more manageable.
Q: Do Giant Souls carry over to NG+2 and beyond?
Yes, they persist across all New Game cycles. Once you have them, you keep them forever.
Q: What happens if I miss a Giant Soul in my first playthrough?
If you miss one, you will not have the full reduction in that playthrough, but you can still get it in New Game Plus. The game does not lock you out of any Giant Souls permanently.
Q: Does the Ancient Dragon drop a Giant Soul every time you kill it?
Yes, the Ancient Dragon always drops the Ancient Dragon Soul when defeated, and it is a guaranteed drop.
Related
Method: the standard formula for this calculation, rounded as each result states. See how the calculators work or report an error.