ThisCalculator

Everyday

New Silicon Opens Quantum Computers?

Updated · Standard formula, shown below

The calculator for this page is switched off while it is checked. The formula is below, and the worked example in the article shows how to use it by hand.

Yes, a new silicon-based approach is opening a practical path toward quantum computers by using standard chip-manufacturing techniques to create stable qubits. This development could allow quantum processors to be built in existing semiconductor factories, potentially overcoming the scalability and cost barriers that have limited other quantum technologies.

Formula

The Zeeman energy splitting for a spin-1/2 particle (like an electron or a phosphorus donor nucleus) in a magnetic field is given by:

E = g · μB · B / h

Where:

  • E = energy splitting (in GHz, after dividing by Planck’s constant)
  • g = electron g-factor (approximately 2.0023 for a free electron, but in silicon it’s about 1.998 for donor-bound electrons)
  • μB = Bohr magneton (13.996 GHz/T)
  • B = magnetic field strength (in Tesla)
  • h = Planck’s constant (converts energy to frequency)

For a phosphorus donor in silicon, the g-factor is close to 2, so the simplified formula is E ≈ 2 × 13.996 × B (in GHz). This energy corresponds to the frequency of microwave radiation needed to flip the qubit’s spin state.

Worked Example

Using the default values from the calculator (Temperature = 0.1 K, Magnetic field = 0.5 T):

  1. Plug the magnetic field into the simplified formula: E = 2 × 13.996 × 0.5
  2. Multiply: 13.996 × 0.5 = 6.998
  3. Double it: 2 × 6.998 = 13.996 GHz

The result is approximately 14.0 GHz, which matches the calculator’s output. This is the microwave frequency needed to drive spin transitions in a silicon qubit at 0.5 T.

Why Silicon Qubits Matter

Silicon is the backbone of modern electronics, and the ability to create qubits in silicon means quantum processors could be manufactured using existing CMOS (complementary metal-oxide-semiconductor) fabrication lines. This is a major advantage over other qubit platforms like superconducting circuits or trapped ions, which require custom, often hand-assembled components.

The key breakthrough came in the 2010s when researchers at UNSW Sydney and Delft University demonstrated that they could isolate and control single phosphorus atoms in silicon, and later that they could use the electron spin and the nuclear spin of the atom as qubits. These spins are extremely stable, with coherence times (how long the quantum state lasts) reaching seconds—far longer than most other qubit types.

How Silicon Qubits Work

There are two main approaches to silicon qubits:

  • Donor-based qubits: Individual phosphorus atoms are implanted in a silicon lattice. The electron spin or the nuclear spin of the phosphorus atom acts as the qubit. Control is achieved with microwave pulses, and readout is done by measuring the spin-dependent tunneling of electrons.
  • Quantum dot qubits: Electrons are confined in tiny semiconductor structures called quantum dots, created by applying voltages to gates on the silicon chip. The spin of a single electron in the dot is the qubit. This approach is more scalable because it uses standard lithography.

Both approaches rely on the same fundamental principle: the spin of an electron (or nucleus) has two states (up and down), which represent 0 and 1. By applying precise microwave pulses, the spin can be rotated to any superposition of these states, enabling quantum computation.

Scalability and Manufacturing

The biggest promise of silicon qubits is manufacturability. Since silicon chips are already produced at massive scale with extreme precision, quantum processors made from silicon could potentially be fabricated in the same factories. This would allow for the integration of quantum and classical electronics on the same chip, which is crucial for control and readout.

However, there are challenges. Qubits require extremely low temperatures (around 0.1 K, or -273°C) to operate, and the control electronics must also work at those temperatures. Recent advances have shown that CMOS circuits can operate at these temperatures, so the vision of a fully integrated silicon quantum chip is becoming more realistic.

Common Problems and Misconceptions

Problem: Qubit variability. Donor-based qubits are difficult to place precisely, leading to variations in coupling and frequency. This makes it hard to scale up to thousands of qubits. Quantum dot qubits are more uniform but still suffer from charge noise and fabrication imperfections.

Misconception: Silicon qubits are ready for commercial use. While the science is promising, current silicon quantum processors have only a few qubits (around 10-20). Error correction, which requires thousands of physical qubits for one logical qubit, is still years away.

Misconception: Silicon qubits are slower than other types. Actually, silicon spin qubits have gate times on the order of nanoseconds, comparable to superconducting qubits, and their long coherence times mean they can perform many operations before losing quantum information.

Comparison with Other Qubit Technologies

Here’s how silicon qubits stack up against the leading alternatives:

  • Superconducting qubits (IBM, Google): Fast, but require complex fabrication and have short coherence times (microseconds). Silicon qubits have longer coherence times and could be easier to scale.
  • Trapped ions (IonQ, Honeywell): Extremely high fidelity, but slow and hard to scale because each ion must be individually controlled with lasers. Silicon qubits are smaller and could be packed more densely.
  • Topological qubits (Microsoft): Theoretically robust but not yet demonstrated. Silicon qubits exist and work today.

Silicon’s main advantage is the existing industrial infrastructure. No other technology can claim that.

Costs and Development Timeline

It’s difficult to estimate the exact cost of silicon quantum computers because they are still in the research phase. However, the cost of a silicon qubit is potentially much lower than other types because it uses standard semiconductor materials and processes. The development timeline is also promising: the Australian government and companies like Silicon Quantum Computing have invested heavily, with a goal of a 10-qubit demonstration by 2025 and a commercial device by 2030.

But don’t expect a desktop quantum computer anytime soon. Even if silicon qubits become scalable, the cryogenic cooling and control electronics will remain expensive and bulky. Quantum computers will likely be accessed via cloud services, like today’s high-performance computing clusters.

Safety and Environmental Considerations

Silicon quantum computers are generally safe, as they operate at extremely low temperatures and low voltages. The main safety concerns are:

  • Cryogenic hazards: Liquid helium and dilution refrigerators involve extreme cold and high pressures, but these are standard laboratory equipment with well-established safety protocols.
  • Radiation: Some qubit fabrication uses ion implantation, which involves radioactive sources, but these are contained and regulated.
  • Environmental impact: The manufacturing process uses hazardous chemicals, but this is the same as conventional chip manufacturing, which is already heavily regulated.

There are no unique safety risks specific to silicon quantum computers.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: How many qubits does a silicon quantum computer have now?
A: As of 2024, the largest silicon quantum processors have around 10-20 qubits, demonstrated by research groups at UNSW and Delft. These are proof-of-concept devices, not yet capable of error-corrected computation.

Q: Can silicon quantum computers run at room temperature?
A: No. Qubits in silicon require temperatures below 1 Kelvin to maintain quantum coherence. At room temperature, thermal vibrations destroy the delicate quantum states. This is true for all qubit types except some photonic approaches.

Q: What is the difference between a silicon qubit and a regular transistor?
A: A transistor operates in a binary state (on/off) and is controlled by voltage. A qubit uses quantum superposition to exist in both states simultaneously, and it is controlled by microwave pulses. The physical structure is similar, but the physics is fundamentally different.

Q: Why are silicon qubits considered more stable than others?
A: Silicon has a very low level of nuclear spin, which means less magnetic noise. The isotope silicon-28 (which has no nuclear spin) can be purified to 99.99%, allowing electron spins to remain coherent for seconds—much longer than superconducting qubits.

Q: When will silicon quantum computers be commercially available?
A: Most experts predict that a silicon quantum computer capable of solving practical problems (like drug discovery or cryptography) is still 10-20 years away. The main hurdle is scaling to thousands of qubits with error correction.

Related

Formula used
in t | Temperature (K) | K | 0.1 | 0
in f | Magnetic field (T) | T | 0.5 | 0
out e | Zeeman energy (GHz) | GHz | 2 * 13.996 * f | 3

Each line is one input (in, sel, list) or one result (out: label, unit, formula, decimals). How the calculators work

Method: the standard formula for this calculation, rounded as each result states. See how the calculators work or report an error.