How to Choose Accessibility Testing Tools
This guide helps developers and designers pick the right accessibility testing tools for their workflow. You’ll learn what to look for based on your role, project stage, and budget, so you can catch issues early and avoid costly fixes. Start by understanding your team’s needs, then follow the steps to evaluate and select tools that fit.
What You’ll Need
- A clear idea of your project’s platforms (web, mobile, desktop) and technologies (React, Angular, iOS, Android, etc.)
- Your team’s workflow: where do you test (CI/CD, manual QA, design handoff)?
- Budget considerations: free vs. paid tools, and how many licenses you need
- Basic knowledge of WCAG (Web Content Accessibility Guidelines) and common accessibility barriers
Step-by-Step
- Define your testing goals. Are you looking to catch automated issues (like missing alt text or low contrast), or do you need help with manual testing (like keyboard navigation or screen reader flows)? Most teams need a mix of both. Write down the top three accessibility problems you want to catch.
- Identify your platforms and tech stack. For web, tools like axe-core, Lighthouse, and WAVE work well. For mobile, you’ll need platform-specific tools like Xcode’s Accessibility Inspector (iOS) or Android’s Accessibility Scanner. If you have a React or Angular app, consider tools that integrate with your testing framework (e.g., jest-axe for unit tests).
- Check integration with your existing workflow. Do you want to run checks in your CI/CD pipeline? Look for tools that offer command-line interfaces or APIs (like axe-core or Lighthouse CI). If you prefer manual testing, browser extensions are easier. For designers, tools like Stark or Figma’s built-in accessibility plugins integrate directly into design tools.
- Evaluate the tool’s coverage and accuracy. No automated tool catches everything. Check what each tool checks for: some focus on WCAG A/AA, others on ARIA, contrast, or form labels. Look for tools that are transparent about their limitations. For example, axe-core has a well-documented list of rules and known false positives.
- Consider the learning curve and reporting. If your team is new to accessibility, choose a tool with clear, actionable reports that explain the issue and how to fix it. Tools like WAVE provide visual overlays on the page, which can be helpful for designers. For developers, tools that output JSON or integrate with issue trackers (Jira, GitHub) are more efficient.
- Test the tool on your own site or a sample. Install the free trial or use the free tier, and run it on a page you know has issues. Does it catch them? Does it produce false positives? How long does it take? This hands-on test is the best way to see if it fits your needs.
- Check for ongoing maintenance and support. Accessibility standards evolve, and tools need updates. Look for tools that are actively maintained (check the last release date and GitHub activity). Also, consider the community and support: is there documentation, a forum, or a Slack channel where you can get help?
- Decide on a combination, not a single tool. No one tool covers everything. A common stack is: a linter for code (eslint-plugin-jsx-a11y), an automated scanner in CI (axe-core), a browser extension for manual checks (WAVE or axe DevTools), and a screen reader for manual testing (NVDA or VoiceOver). For designers, a Figma plugin like Stark can catch contrast issues early.
- Plan for manual testing. Automated tools only catch about 30-50% of issues. You’ll still need to test with a keyboard, screen reader, and zoom. Choose tools that facilitate manual testing, such as a keyboard-only testing checklist or screen reader guides.
- Review cost and licensing. Many tools have free tiers or open-source options (axe-core, Lighthouse, WAVE). Paid tools like Deque’s axe DevTools Pro or Silktide offer advanced features, team management, and support. Decide based on your budget and the value of the features you need.
Common Mistakes
- Relying solely on automated tools. They miss many issues like keyboard traps, focus order, and screen reader context. Always pair with manual testing.
- Choosing a tool that doesn’t fit your workflow. If you test in CI, a browser extension alone won’t help. If you’re a designer, a code-based linter is not useful.
- Ignoring false positives. Some tools flag issues that aren’t real problems, leading to wasted time. Learn to interpret results and configure rules where needed.
- Not testing early and often. Accessibility is easier to fix during design and development. Waiting until the end leads to expensive rework.
- Overlooking the need for user testing. Tools can’t replace feedback from people with disabilities. Use tools to catch issues, but also involve real users when possible.
Tips
- Start with a free tool like axe DevTools or Lighthouse to get baseline awareness.
- Create a shared accessibility checklist for your team, and use tools to automate the checks that can be automated.
- For designers, integrate contrast checking into your design tool (e.g., Stark for Figma) to catch issues before developers start.
- Use the same tool across the team to ensure consistent results and shared knowledge.
- Keep an eye on the tool’s roadmap and community; accessibility is a fast-moving field.
- Remember that tools are a means, not an end: the goal is to make your product usable for everyone.
Troubleshooting
If a tool isn’t working as expected, try these steps:
- Tool doesn’t detect an issue you know exists. Check the tool’s documentation for known limitations. Some tools don’t check for certain WCAG criteria (like 1.3.1 Info and Relationships). If it’s a common gap, consider a complementary tool.
- Too many false positives. Look for a way to configure rules or add exclusions. For example, axe allows you to disable specific rules in your config. Or, the issue might be a false positive due to a dynamic element; verify manually.
- Tool slows down your CI pipeline. Optimize by running the scanner only on changed files or using a lighter-weight tool. Also, consider running accessibility tests in a separate job or on a schedule.
- Designers and developers see different results. Ensure both use the same version of the tool and the same test page. For design tools, the code may not match the design; use the tool as a guide, not a definitive check.
- Screen reader testing is overwhelming. Start with a simple checklist: navigate with Tab, read the page with the screen reader, and check forms. Use a tool like the W3C’s WAI-ARIA Authoring Practices for guidance.
Frequently Asked Questions
What’s the best free accessibility testing tool?
There’s no single “best,” but axe DevTools (free tier), Lighthouse, and WAVE are popular and reliable. Each has strengths: axe is great for developers, Lighthouse gives a performance and accessibility score, and WAVE is visual and easy for designers.
Can automated tools find all accessibility issues?
No, they typically catch 30-50% of issues. Automated tools are good at detecting missing alt text, low contrast, and some ARIA errors, but they can’t judge if a page is understandable or if keyboard navigation works logically. Manual testing is essential.
Do I need separate tools for web and mobile?
Yes, because the platforms are different. For web, use browser-based tools. For iOS, use Xcode’s Accessibility Inspector; for Android, use Accessibility Scanner. Some cross-platform tools like Appium have accessibility checks, but they’re not as comprehensive as native tools.
How often should I run accessibility tests?
Run automated checks on every code change (in CI) and before each release. Do a manual accessibility pass at least once per sprint or before major releases. The earlier you catch issues, the cheaper they are to fix.
What’s the difference between WCAG and Section 508?
WCAG is an international standard (ISO/IEC 40500) that defines how to make web content accessible. Section 508 is a US federal law that requires government agencies to make their electronic and information technology accessible, and it references WCAG 2.0 Level AA. Many tools let you choose which standard to test against.
Should I use a paid tool or is free enough?
Free tools are enough to start and for many small projects. Paid tools often offer better reporting, team collaboration, and support, which can be worth it for larger organizations or those with strict compliance needs. Evaluate your specific requirements and budget.
Related
Method: the standard formula for this calculation, rounded as each result states. See how the calculators work or report an error.