ThisCalculator

Everyday

Malware Blocking DNS Test: What It Proves

Updated · Standard formula, shown below

This article explains what a malware blocking test of DNS services like Cloudflare, Quad9, NextDNS, and AdGuard DNS can and cannot prove. You will learn what these tests measure, how the services differ, and how to interpret the results for your own security needs.

Background: The Role of DNS in Malware Blocking

The Domain Name System (DNS) is the internet’s phonebook, translating human-friendly names like example.com into IP addresses. When you type a URL, your device queries a DNS resolver to find the correct server. Malware often relies on domain names to connect to command-and-control (C2) servers, distribute payloads, or exfiltrate data. By blocking access to known malicious domains at the DNS level, a resolver can prevent your device from reaching these harmful sites, even if other defenses fail.

Cloudflare, Quad9, NextDNS, and AdGuard DNS are public DNS resolvers that offer varying levels of threat blocking. They maintain blocklists of domains associated with malware, phishing, botnets, and other threats. When you query one of these services, it checks the domain against its blocklist and returns a non-routable IP address (like 0.0.0.0) if the domain is flagged, effectively stopping the connection.

How Malware Blocking Tests Work

A typical malware blocking test uses a set of known malicious domain names—often from sources like the Malware Domain Blocklist or the Spamhaus Domain Block List—and queries each DNS service to see if it returns a block. The test measures the percentage of domains that are blocked, which is often called the “block rate” or “detection rate.”

For example, a test might use 100 domains that are currently active on malware distribution sites. It then sends a DNS query for each domain to each resolver and records whether the response is an IP address (not blocked) or a block page/zero IP (blocked). The higher the block rate, the more effective the service is at preventing access to those specific threats.

However, the test only reflects the blocklist coverage at that moment. Blocklists change constantly as new threats emerge and old domains are taken down. A service that blocks 90% of a test set today might block a different percentage tomorrow.

What the Test Results Actually Prove

The primary thing a malware blocking test proves is the coverage of a service’s blocklist against a specific set of domains. It shows how many of those particular domains are known to the service and actively blocked. This is useful for comparing the relative breadth of different blocklists.

But the test does not prove the overall security effectiveness of a service. A high block rate on a small test set does not guarantee protection against zero-day (newly created) domains, which blocklists may not yet know about. It also does not measure how quickly a service updates its blocklist after a new threat appears, which is a critical factor in real-world protection.

Furthermore, the test does not evaluate other security features like DNS-over-HTTPS (DoH) encryption, which prevents eavesdropping and tampering with DNS queries. A service with a lower block rate but strong encryption might be more secure in some contexts than a service with a higher block rate but no encryption.

Comparing Cloudflare, Quad9, NextDNS, and AdGuard

Each of these services takes a different approach to blocking:

  • Cloudflare (1.1.1.1) offers a security-focused DNS (1.1.1.2 for malware blocking, 1.1.1.3 for malware + adult content). Its blocklist is based on threat intelligence from Cloudflare’s own network and third-party feeds. It is known for speed and privacy, but its blocklist is generally considered less comprehensive than some dedicated security DNS services.
  • Quad9 (9.9.9.9) is a non-profit service that aggregates blocklists from multiple industry partners, including IBM X-Force and the Global Cyber Alliance. It blocks domains associated with malware, phishing, botnets, and other threats. Quad9 does not log IP addresses, making it privacy-friendly.
  • NextDNS is a cloud-based DNS service that allows users to create custom blocklists, set filtering rules, and view analytics. It offers a free tier and a paid subscription. Its default blocklist includes several major threat lists, and users can add more.
  • AdGuard DNS is primarily known for ad blocking, but it also offers a malware blocking variant (94.140.14.14). It uses its own blocklist and third-party lists to block ads, trackers, and malicious domains. It has both free and paid versions.

In a typical malware blocking test, Quad9 and NextDNS often score higher than Cloudflare because they are specifically designed for security. AdGuard DNS scores well too, but its focus on ad blocking may dilute its malware-specific coverage.

Common Misconceptions and Limitations

One common misconception is that a high block rate means the service is “the best.” But block rate is only one metric. A service might block 95% of a test set but have slower response times or less reliable uptime. Another misconception is that DNS blocking alone makes you invulnerable to malware. DNS blocking only prevents connections to known malicious domains; it does not scan files for viruses or block malicious content embedded in otherwise legitimate sites.

Another limitation is that test sets are often small (e.g., 100 domains) and may not be representative of the broader threat landscape. Some tests use domains that are already dead or unreachable, which can inflate block rates. Conversely, a test might use very new domains that no blocklist has yet, leading to low scores for all services.

Additionally, DNS-based blocking can be bypassed by malware that uses hardcoded IP addresses instead of domain names, or by using a different DNS resolver that does not block. In such cases, the DNS service is irrelevant.

How to Choose a DNS Service for Malware Blocking

When deciding which service to use, consider your specific needs:

  • Security focus: If you want maximum malware blocking, choose a service like Quad9 or NextDNS with a dedicated security blocklist.
  • Privacy: If you are concerned about logging, look for services that do not store IP addresses, such as Quad9 or Cloudflare (which claims to delete logs within 24 hours).
  • Customization: If you want to control what is blocked, NextDNS and AdGuard offer user-defined lists and filtering rules.
  • Speed: Cloudflare is often cited as one of the fastest resolvers, but speed differences are usually negligible for typical users.
  • Ease of setup: All four services support configuration on routers, operating systems, and browsers. Some, like NextDNS, offer dedicated apps for mobile and desktop.

You can also run your own malware blocking test using tools like dnscheck or by manually querying domains with dig. However, for a reliable comparison, use a reputable third-party test that uses a large, current dataset.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can a malware blocking test guarantee that I won’t get infected?

No. A test only shows how well a DNS service blocks a specific list of known malicious domains. It cannot protect against zero-day threats, malvertising, or social engineering. DNS blocking is one layer of defense, but you still need antivirus software, a firewall, and safe browsing habits.

Why does Cloudflare often score lower than Quad9 in tests?

Cloudflare’s primary focus is speed and privacy, not security. Its blocklist is smaller and less frequently updated compared to Quad9, which aggregates multiple threat intelligence feeds specifically for security. That said, Cloudflare still blocks many known malware domains, just not as many as dedicated security services.

Are there any risks in using a public DNS resolver?

Generally, no, but you are trusting the provider to handle your DNS queries. Some providers log data, which could be a privacy concern. Also, if the provider’s service goes down, you lose DNS resolution. Using a reliable provider with good uptime and a clear privacy policy mitigates these risks.

Can I combine multiple DNS services for better protection?

You cannot use two DNS resolvers simultaneously for the same query, but you can set up a secondary resolver as a fallback. Some routers allow you to specify multiple DNS servers. However, using a service like NextDNS that aggregates multiple blocklists is a more practical way to get broad coverage.

Do these services block ads and trackers too?

Only AdGuard DNS and NextDNS (with custom lists) block ads and trackers by default. Cloudflare and Quad9 focus solely on malware and phishing. If you want ad blocking, you might prefer AdGuard or NextDNS, but be aware that aggressive ad blocking can break some websites.

How often are blocklists updated?

Update frequency varies. Quad9 updates its blocklist multiple times a day, while NextDNS updates in near real-time. Cloudflare updates its list regularly, but not as frequently as dedicated security services. For the most current protection, choose a service that updates at least hourly.

Related

Method: the standard formula for this calculation, rounded as each result states. See how the calculators work or report an error.