Pool RAM Across Computers for Larger AI Models?
Yes, you can pool RAM across multiple computers to run a larger AI model, but it is not a simple plug-and-play solution and comes with significant trade-offs. This approach, often called distributed inference or memory pooling, allows models that exceed a single machine’s RAM to run by spreading the model’s weights across several machines. However, the speed of the connection between machines becomes the bottleneck, and you may see inference speeds that are far slower than running the model on a single machine with enough memory.
Why Pooling RAM Is Tempting
Large language models and other AI models are measured in parameters—the weights and biases that define the model. A 70-billion-parameter model, for example, needs roughly 140 GB of RAM just to store its weights in 16-bit precision (2 bytes per parameter). A 405-billion-parameter model needs over 800 GB. Consumer desktops and even many workstations simply don’t have that much memory. Pooling RAM across several machines seems like an obvious way to get the memory capacity you need without buying a single expensive server.
This is different from cloud-based model APIs, where the model runs on a remote server. Here, you own the hardware and want to run the model locally, but the model is too big for one machine.
How Distributed Inference Actually Works
When you pool RAM across computers, you are not creating a single shared memory space like a distributed shared memory system. Instead, you split the model’s layers or tensors across the machines. Each machine holds a slice of the model’s weights. During inference, data flows through the model: the first machine processes its layers, then sends the intermediate results to the next machine, and so on.
This is exactly how model parallelism works on a single machine with multiple GPUs, but with a crucial difference: the interconnect. On a single machine, GPUs talk to each other over NVLink or PCIe, which offer hundreds of gigabytes per second of bandwidth. Across computers, you are limited to your network—typically 1 GbE (about 125 MB/s), 10 GbE (about 1.25 GB/s), or Wi-Fi (often slower and less stable).
For a model with 70 billion parameters, even a single forward pass requires moving hundreds of gigabytes of data between machines. At 1 GbE, that would take minutes per token, making the model unusable for any interactive task. At 10 GbE, it becomes feasible for batch processing, but still far slower than a single GPU.
Software That Supports Pooling
Several open-source projects have implemented this idea, each with its own approach:
- DeepSpeed (from Microsoft) includes a feature called ZeRO-Inference that can offload model parameters to CPU or NVMe, and it also supports multi-node inference. It is designed for high-performance clusters, not casual home networks.
- Petals (from BigScience) is specifically built for running large models like BLOOM across multiple machines. It treats the model as a distributed service, where each machine runs a few layers. It is designed for consumer hardware and can work over the internet, but it is still slow for interactive use.
- llama.cpp has an RPC backend that allows you to split a model across multiple machines. It is one of the most accessible options for hobbyists, but again, performance depends heavily on network speed.
- FlexGen (from Stanford) focuses on offloading to CPU and disk on a single machine, but its ideas can be extended to multiple machines.
None of these are as simple as installing a driver. They require configuration, and you need to understand how model parallelism works.
When It Makes Sense
Pooling RAM is rarely the best choice for interactive use, but it can be useful in specific scenarios:
- Batch inference: If you need to process a large amount of text offline and don’t care about latency, pooling RAM can work. You can run the model overnight and get results by morning.
- Testing and experimentation: If you want to see how a model behaves without buying a dedicated server, pooling RAM lets you try it out, even if it’s slow.
- Cost avoidance: If you already have several machines with spare RAM, pooling them is cheaper than buying a new machine with 1 TB of RAM.
- Research: Some researchers use distributed inference to run models that exceed the memory of any single node in their cluster, even if they have to wait.
Common Problems and Misconceptions
The biggest misconception is that pooling RAM gives you a single fast machine. It doesn’t. The network is the bottleneck, and it is orders of magnitude slower than local memory. Even with 10 GbE, the bandwidth is roughly 10-20 times slower than a single GPU’s memory bandwidth.
Another issue is synchronization. In a pipeline-parallel setup, if one machine is slower than the others, the whole pipeline stalls. This can happen if the machines have different CPU speeds or if the network has latency spikes.
There is also the problem of fault tolerance. If one machine goes down, the entire inference fails. For long batch jobs, this can be frustrating.
Finally, memory overhead: the intermediate activations (the results between layers) also need to be stored, and they can be as large as the weights themselves. So you need more than just the model’s size in total RAM.
Alternatives to Pooling
Before you go down the pooling route, consider these alternatives:
- Use a smaller model: A 7B or 13B model can run on a single consumer GPU with quantization. Many tasks don’t need a 70B model.
- Quantization: Reduce the precision of the weights from 16-bit to 8-bit or 4-bit. This can cut memory usage by 4x or more, with a small quality loss.
- CPU offloading: Run the model on a single machine, using both GPU and CPU RAM. This is simpler than pooling and can be fast enough for batch processing.
- Cloud API: Use a hosted API if you only need the model occasionally. It may be cheaper than buying hardware.
- Single high-RAM machine: A used server with 512 GB of RAM can be cheaper than you think, and it avoids the network bottleneck entirely.
Costs and Practicalities
Pooling RAM costs you network hardware. To get usable performance, you need at least 10 GbE, which requires a switch and network cards on each machine. That can cost a few hundred dollars. You also need to consider electricity and cooling if you run the machines 24/7.
Time is also a cost. Setting up a distributed inference system takes hours, and debugging network issues can take longer. If your time is valuable, a single machine with enough RAM might be simpler.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I pool RAM over Wi-Fi?
Technically yes, but it will be extremely slow. Wi-Fi bandwidth is typically 100-500 MB/s, and latency is high. For a 70B model, you would be waiting minutes per token. It’s not practical for anything but the smallest models.
Will pooling RAM let me run a model that doesn’t fit on any single machine?
Yes, that is the main purpose. As long as the total RAM across all machines is greater than the model size plus overhead, you can run it. But the speed will be limited by the slowest link in the network.
Does pooling RAM work with GPUs?
Yes, you can pool GPU memory across machines, but the same network bottleneck applies. In fact, GPU-to-GPU communication over network is even more constrained because GPUs expect high-bandwidth interconnects.
What is the minimum network speed for usable pooling?
For interactive use, you likely need 100 GbE or faster, which is rare outside data centers. For batch processing, 10 GbE is the minimum you’d want. At 1 GbE, it’s almost always too slow.
Can I pool RAM from a cloud VM and my local machine?
Yes, but the internet connection between them will be the bottleneck. Cloud VMs often have high bandwidth, but your home connection is the limiting factor. It’s usually not worth it.
Is pooling RAM the same as distributed training?
No. Distributed training is about speeding up training by using multiple machines, and it has different algorithms and requirements. Pooling RAM for inference is a simpler concept, but it doesn’t speed up computation—it only increases memory capacity.
Related
Method: the standard formula for this calculation, rounded as each result states. See how the calculators work or report an error.