Xbox Game Pass vs Switch Online: Pick by Platform
If you own both an Xbox and a Nintendo Switch, the practical answer is: get Xbox Game Pass for the Xbox and Nintendo Switch Online for the Switch—they serve different platforms and different game libraries. If you can only afford one subscription, choose the one that matches the console you play most, because neither service works on the other’s hardware. This article breaks down what each service offers, how they differ, and how to decide based on your gaming habits.
Background: What Each Service Is
Xbox Game Pass is Microsoft’s subscription service for Xbox consoles, PC, and cloud gaming (via Xbox Cloud Gaming). It gives you access to a rotating catalog of hundreds of games—from big first-party titles like Halo and Forza to indie gems—for a monthly fee. There are three tiers: Console, PC, and Ultimate (which combines both plus cloud gaming and Xbox Live Gold).
Nintendo Switch Online is Nintendo’s subscription service for the Switch, offering online multiplayer, cloud saves, and a library of classic NES, SNES, and Game Boy games. It has two tiers: the standard plan and the Expansion Pack, which adds Nintendo 64, Sega Genesis, and some DLC (like Mario Kart 8 Deluxe’s Booster Course Pass).
The key difference: Game Pass is a modern-game library service; Switch Online is primarily an online-play and retro-game service. They are not direct competitors, but people often compare them when deciding which subscription to buy.
How Each Service Works
Xbox Game Pass
- Catalog: Over 400 games at any time, including all new first-party Xbox games on day one.
- Platforms: Xbox Series X|S, Xbox One, PC (with PC Game Pass), and mobile/tablet via cloud streaming (Ultimate only).
- Multiplayer: Requires Xbox Game Pass Ultimate (includes Xbox Live Gold) for online play on console.
- Pricing: Console and PC plans are cheaper; Ultimate combines everything.
Nintendo Switch Online
- Catalog: A few hundred classic games from older consoles; no modern games included.
- Platforms: Nintendo Switch only.
- Multiplayer: Required for online play in most Switch games (e.g., Splatoon 3, Mario Kart 8 Deluxe).
- Pricing: Individual or family plans; Expansion Pack costs more.
Game Library: Modern vs. Retro
The most significant difference is the type of games you get. Game Pass is all about current and recent titles. When Microsoft releases a new first-party game like Starfield or Forza Motorsport, it appears on Game Pass the same day. You also get third-party games, often on launch day or within a few months. The catalog changes monthly, with games added and removed, but many stay for a year or more.
Switch Online’s library is almost entirely retro. The base tier includes NES and SNES games like Super Mario Bros. and The Legend of Zelda: A Link to the Past. The Expansion Pack adds N64 and Genesis titles like Mario Kart 64 and Sonic the Hedgehog 2. These are emulated versions, not remasters. If you grew up with these games, it’s a nostalgia trip; if you want new experiences, it’s not.
One common misconception: people assume Switch Online includes modern Switch games. It does not. You still have to buy those separately. Game Pass, on the other hand, is a “Netflix for games� for current titles.
Cost Comparison
Pricing changes over time, but generally:
- Xbox Game Pass Console: ~$10–11/month (US)
- Xbox Game Pass PC: ~$10/month
- Xbox Game Pass Ultimate: ~$17–18/month (includes console, PC, cloud, and online multiplayer)
- Nintendo Switch Online (individual): ~$4/month or ~$20/year
- Nintendo Switch Online + Expansion Pack: ~$50/year
Switch Online is far cheaper, but you get far less. Game Pass Ultimate is expensive, but it replaces the need to buy many full-priced games. If you play a lot of third-party and first-party Xbox titles, Game Pass can save you hundreds of dollars a year. If you only play a few Switch games online, the base Switch Online plan is trivial.
How to Choose Based on Your Platform
Here’s a decision framework:
- Which console do you play most? If it’s Xbox, get Game Pass. If it’s Switch, get Switch Online.
- Do you play online multiplayer on Switch? If yes, you need Switch Online (or a family plan). It’s non-negotiable for most online games.
- Do you buy many new games? If you buy 2–3 full-priced games a year on Xbox, Game Pass pays for itself. If you rarely buy games, a subscription may not be worth it.
- Do you have a PC? PC Game Pass is a separate, cheaper option if you don’t own an Xbox.
- Are you interested in cloud gaming? Game Pass Ultimate lets you play on phones and low-end PCs via streaming. Switch Online has no cloud gaming.
Common Problems and Misconceptions
“Can I play Game Pass on Switch?�
No. Game Pass is not available on Nintendo hardware. There is no official app or streaming method. Similarly, Switch Online is not available on Xbox. The two ecosystems are completely separate.
“Does Game Pass include online multiplayer?�
Only if you have Game Pass Ultimate. The base Console and PC plans do not include Xbox Live Gold, which is required for online play on Xbox. If you play online on Xbox, you need Ultimate or a separate Gold subscription.
“Does Switch Online include cloud saves?�
Yes, for most games, but not all. Some titles (like Animal Crossing: New Horizons) have special cloud save restrictions. Game Pass also offers cloud saves for Xbox games.
“Are all games on Game Pass forever?�
No. Games rotate in and out. Microsoft’s first-party titles stay, but third-party games are licensed for a set period. Once a game leaves, you can’t play it unless you buy it.
Which Is Better Value?
Value depends on your play style. For a family with a Switch, the family plan for Switch Online (up to 8 accounts) is extremely cheap and covers online play and retro games. For a solo gamer who loves new AAA titles, Game Pass Ultimate is a better deal because it replaces purchases.
If you only have a Switch, Game Pass is irrelevant. If you only have an Xbox, Switch Online is irrelevant. The only real decision is if you own both and want to cut costs. In that case, prioritize the service that matches your primary console. Many players keep both, but if you must choose, think about which console you’d miss more if you couldn’t play its exclusive games.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I use Xbox Game Pass on Nintendo Switch?
No. Xbox Game Pass is only available on Xbox consoles, Windows PCs, and mobile devices via cloud streaming (with Ultimate). It does not work on Nintendo Switch hardware.
Does Nintendo Switch Online include any modern games?
No. The service includes only retro games from NES, SNES, N64, and Sega Genesis (with the Expansion Pack). Modern Switch games are sold separately.
Is Xbox Game Pass Ultimate worth it if I only play on console?
Possibly. Ultimate includes console Game Pass plus Xbox Live Gold for online multiplayer. If you play online, it’s often cheaper than buying Game Pass and Gold separately. If you don’t play online, the cheaper Console plan may be enough.
Can I play Game Pass games on PC if I have a console subscription?
No. Console Game Pass is separate from PC Game Pass. You need Game Pass Ultimate to get both on one subscription.
Do I need Nintendo Switch Online to play free-to-play games like Fortnite?
No. Free-to-play games on Switch do not require a Nintendo Switch Online subscription for online play. This is a common exception.
Which service has more games?
Xbox Game Pass has a larger library (400+ games) and includes modern titles. Nintendo Switch Online has a smaller library (a few hundred retro games) but is much cheaper.
Related
Method: the standard formula for this calculation, rounded as each result states. See how the calculators work or report an error.