3D Scanner for 3D Printing: What to Look For
To choose a 3D scanner for 3D printing, focus on accuracy, resolution, and software compatibility, because these directly determine how faithfully your printed model matches the scanned object. You also need to consider the scanner’s capture volume, portability, and price, since these affect which objects you can scan and how often you’ll actually use it. This guide breaks down the key specifications, common pitfalls, and practical tips to help you pick a scanner that fits your workflow.
How 3D Scanning Works
3D scanners capture the shape of a physical object by measuring thousands of points on its surface and converting them into a digital mesh (STL or OBJ file). The two most common technologies in consumer and prosumer scanners are:
- Structured light: Projects a pattern of light onto the object and analyzes how the pattern deforms to calculate depth. Fast and highly accurate for small to medium objects, but struggles in bright ambient light and with shiny or dark surfaces.
- Laser triangulation: Sweeps a laser line across the object and uses a camera to measure the line’s displacement. Works in varied lighting, but is slower and often requires turntable rotation for full coverage.
Photogrammetry (using a smartphone camera and software like Meshroom or Metashape) is a low-cost alternative, but it needs good lighting, many overlapping photos, and significant processing time. It’s less accurate for fine details than dedicated scanners.
Key Specifications to Compare
When comparing scanners, look at these numbers on the spec sheet:
- Accuracy: The deviation between the scanned mesh and the real object, usually stated in millimeters (e.g., ±0.05 mm). For 3D printing, aim for ±0.1 mm or better; higher accuracy is needed for engineering fits.
- Resolution: The smallest feature the scanner can capture, often expressed as a point spacing (e.g., 0.2 mm). Higher resolution captures fine details like text or small threads.
- Capture volume: The maximum object size the scanner can handle in one pass. Small scanners might handle objects up to 30 cm, while larger ones can capture a full human body (but require more space).
- Frame rate: How many scans per second the device captures. A higher frame rate (e.g., 10–30 fps) makes handheld scanning smoother and reduces motion blur.
- Software bundle: Does it include mesh processing (alignment, hole filling, decimation)? Some scanners require separate paid software, which adds hidden cost.
How to Choose Based on Your Use Case
Your intended prints dictate the scanner you need:
- Miniatures and small parts (under 10 cm): A turntable-based structured light scanner with a resolution of 0.1 mm or better. Examples include the Creality CR-Scan 01 or the Revopoint POP series.
- Medium objects (10–50 cm): A handheld scanner with a capture volume that can handle a human head or a small mechanical part. The EinScan-SP is a common choice for this range.
- Large objects (over 50 cm) or full body: Professional-grade scanners like the Artec Eva or the EinScan Pro HD, which cost several thousand dollars and require a computer with a strong GPU.
- Budget and hobby use: A smartphone photogrammetry app (e.g., Polycam) or a cheap turntable scanner under $500. You’ll trade accuracy and ease for cost.
Common Problems and How to Avoid Them
Even a good scanner will produce poor results if you don’t control the environment and the object:
- Shiny or reflective surfaces: They confuse the light pattern. Solution: spray the object with a matte temporary coating (e.g., AESUB) or use a fine powder like talc.
- Dark or black surfaces: They absorb the projected light. Solution: lighten the surface with a temporary white spray or scan in a well-lit room.
- Ambient light interference: Direct sunlight or bright overhead LEDs can wash out the pattern. Solution: close blinds, turn off overhead lights, and use a desk lamp with a diffuser.
- Holes in the mesh: Thin features (like a chair’s legs) or undercuts may not be captured. Solution: scan from multiple angles and use the software’s hole-filling tool, but expect some manual cleanup.
- Alignment drift: When scanning a large object in multiple passes, the software may misalign the patches. Solution: use fixed markers (small stickers) on the object to help the software track.
Costs: Entry-Level to Professional
Prices vary widely, and you often get what you pay for:
- Under $500: Basic turntable scanners (e.g., Revopoint POP 2) or DIY photogrammetry setups. Expect accuracy around ±0.2 mm and limited capture volume.
- $500–$2,000: Mid-range handheld scanners (e.g., Creality CR-Scan 01, EinScan-SE) with better accuracy (±0.1 mm) and software that includes mesh processing.
- $2,000–$10,000: Professional portable scanners (e.g., EinScan Pro HD, Artec Eva) with high resolution, fast capture, and reliable tracking. Used by dental labs, engineering firms, and museums.
- Above $10,000: Industrial metrology scanners (e.g., GOM ATOS) with accuracy in the microns, used for quality control and reverse engineering in aerospace and automotive.
Don’t forget the hidden costs: a computer that meets the software’s GPU requirements, a turntable (if not included), and possibly a license for advanced mesh processing software like Geomagic Wrap.
Software and File Formats
The scanner’s software is as important as the hardware. Look for:
- Export formats: STL and OBJ are essential for 3D printing. Some scanners also export PLY, which preserves color.
- Mesh editing tools: The ability to crop, smooth, fill holes, and decimate (reduce polygon count) without leaving the scanner’s software saves time.
- Alignment methods: Automatic alignment using markers or features is easier than manual alignment, especially for large objects.
- Compatibility: Check that the scanner works with your operating system (Windows is most common; macOS support is rare). Some scanners require a USB 3.0 port and a dedicated GPU.
Alternatives to Dedicated Scanners
If you’re not ready to invest in a scanner, consider these alternatives:
- Photogrammetry with a smartphone: Apps like Polycam or 3DF Zephyr use your phone’s camera to create a 3D model. Good for medium objects with lots of texture, but poor for featureless or shiny surfaces.
- Using existing CAD files: If the object is a common part (e.g., a gear or a bracket), search online databases like Thingiverse or GrabCAD for a ready-made model.
- Measuring with calipers and modeling: For simple geometric shapes, manual measurement and CAD modeling (Fusion 360, Tinkercad) may be faster and more accurate than scanning.
- 3D scanning services: Send your object to a service bureau (e.g., Sculpteo, Shapeways) that will scan it for you. This is cost-effective for one-off projects.
Safety and Accuracy Tips
While 3D scanners are generally safe, follow these precautions:
- Laser scanners: Avoid looking directly into the laser beam. Class 1 or Class 2 lasers are safe for skin, but never point them at eyes.
- Spray coatings: Use temporary scanning sprays in a well-ventilated area; they contain solvents that can be harmful if inhaled.
- Accuracy checks: Always calibrate the scanner with a known reference object (e.g., a cube of known dimensions) before critical scans. Recalibrate if you move the scanner or change the lighting.
- Units: Ensure the software is set to the same units (mm, cm, inches) that your slicer uses. A common mistake is scanning in inches and printing in millimeters, which scales the model by 25.4x.
Frequently Asked Questions
What accuracy do I need for 3D printing?
For most hobbyist FDM printing, an accuracy of ±0.2 mm is sufficient, since layer lines are typically 0.1–0.3 mm. For resin printing or engineering fits, you’ll want ±0.05 mm or better. Remember that the printer itself adds its own inaccuracy, so scanning to a higher precision than the printer can achieve is often pointless.
Can I use my smartphone as a 3D scanner?
Yes, with photogrammetry apps like Polycam or Scann3D, but the results are less reliable than dedicated scanners. You need good lighting, a textured object, and many overlapping photos. For simple objects, it can work well, but for complex or shiny parts, a dedicated scanner is worth the money.
Why does my scan have holes and missing areas?
Holes occur where the scanner cannot see the surface—typically in undercuts, dark spots, or reflective areas. Improve lighting, apply a matte spray, and scan from more angles. Most scanning software includes a hole-filling tool, but large holes may require manual mesh editing.
What’s the difference between a turntable scanner and a handheld scanner?
A turntable scanner rotates the object while the scanner stays still, which is great for small, rigid objects but cannot handle large or irregular shapes. A handheld scanner is moved around the object, allowing you to capture larger scenes, but it requires steady hands and good tracking software to avoid drift.
Do I need to post-process the scanned mesh before printing?
Yes, almost always. The raw scan will have noise, holes, and a high polygon count. Use the scanner’s software or a tool like Meshmixer to clean up the mesh, fill holes, and reduce polygon count before exporting to STL. Then run it through your slicer’s repair function if needed.
Can I scan a person for 3D printing?
Yes, but it requires a scanner with a large capture volume and fast capture speed to avoid motion blur. Professional full-body scanners cost thousands. For a head bust, a handheld scanner with a turntable can work, but the person must sit still for a few minutes.
Related
Method: the standard formula for this calculation, rounded as each result states. See how the calculators work or report an error.