ThisCalculator

Everyday

SUV Tanks in Value Rivals Do Better?

Updated · Standard formula, shown below

Estimated value 19,250 USD
Purchase price
35000 USD
You entered
Age
3 years
You entered

This article answers a common question: do SUVs hold their value better than their rivals? The short answer is that many SUVs depreciate slower than comparable sedans and hatchbacks, but this is not universal—some SUVs lose value faster than a well-regarded sedan from the same brand. The real picture depends on fuel prices, brand reputation, reliability, and the specific model’s supply and demand.

Formula

The calculator above uses a simple linear depreciation model to estimate an SUV’s value after a given number of years. The formula is:

Value = Purchase Price × (0.85 − 0.10 × Age)

Where:

  • Purchase Price (USD) – the original price you paid or the MSRP.
  • Age (years) – how many years since the vehicle was first registered.
  • Value (USD) – the estimated current market value.

This model assumes a 15% drop in the first year and then about 10% each following year. Real-world depreciation is rarely this smooth—it’s often steeper in the first year and then flattens—but this gives a quick ballpark.

Worked Example

Using the default values from the calculator: a $35,000 SUV after 3 years.

  1. Start with the purchase price: $35,000.
  2. Apply the age factor: 0.85 − (0.10 × 3) = 0.85 − 0.30 = 0.55.
  3. Multiply: $35,000 × 0.55 = $19,250.

So the estimated value after 3 years is $19,250. This matches the calculator’s output.

Why SUVs Often Hold Value Better

SUVs have gained popularity over the past two decades, and that demand keeps used prices relatively high. When more people want a used SUV than there are available, prices stay firm. This is especially true for compact and mid-size SUVs that offer a balance of space, fuel economy, and price. In contrast, many sedans have seen declining demand in markets like North America, which pushes their used prices down faster.

Another factor is that SUVs are often built on truck-like platforms or shared with commercial vehicles, which can make them more durable. Models with a reputation for reliability—like certain Japanese or Korean brands—tend to depreciate slower because buyers trust they will last. Also, SUVs often have higher initial prices, so even a similar percentage loss means a higher absolute dollar amount, but the percentage is what matters when comparing value retention.

When Rivals Do Better

Not every SUV beats its rivals. Here are cases where a sedan or hatchback might hold value better:

  • Fuel prices spike: When gas prices rise sharply, fuel-efficient sedans and hybrids become more desirable, and their used prices can hold or even increase.
  • Luxury SUVs: High-end SUVs often depreciate rapidly because their original prices are high, and maintenance costs scare off used buyers.
  • Electric SUVs: Battery degradation concerns and rapid technology changes can cause faster depreciation than a comparable petrol sedan.
  • Niche models: A sports sedan like a Civic Type R or a WRX may hold value better than a mainstream SUV because of enthusiast demand.

For example, a compact SUV like a Honda CR-V typically retains around 60% of its value after 3 years, while a Honda Accord might retain around 55%. But a full-size luxury SUV like a Range Rover can drop to 40% in the same period, worse than many sedans.

How to Choose a Vehicle That Holds Value

If you care about resale value, here are practical tips:

  1. Check historical data: Look at 3-year-old models of the same generation to see what they sell for today.
  2. Choose reliable brands: Toyota, Honda, Subaru, and Lexus often top depreciation charts.
  3. Pick popular body styles: Compact SUVs and pickup trucks generally hold value well.
  4. Consider fuel economy: A vehicle that’s cheap to run will attract more buyers later.
  5. Avoid excessive options: Extra features rarely add the same percentage to resale value as they cost new.
  6. Keep mileage reasonable: High mileage hurts value disproportionately on SUVs.

Also, a vehicle’s color, service history, and accident-free record matter more than the badge.

Common Mistakes in Comparing Depreciation

One common mistake is comparing different age vehicles. A 5-year-old SUV will naturally have a lower percentage retained than a 2-year-old sedan. Always compare vehicles of the same age and similar mileage.

Another error is ignoring incentives. If a brand offers big discounts on a new sedan, that immediately lowers its used value because buyers can get a new one for barely more. SUVs often have fewer incentives because demand is high.

Also, people forget about maintenance costs. A vehicle that costs more to repair may have a lower resale value even if it’s the same age and mileage as a cheaper-to-maintain rival.

Costs Beyond Depreciation

Depreciation is just one cost of ownership. SUVs typically use more fuel, have higher insurance premiums, and cost more for tires and brakes. However, they often have lower repair costs than luxury sedans. When comparing value, you should calculate total cost of ownership: depreciation + fuel + insurance + maintenance + taxes. A vehicle that holds value well but costs a fortune to run may not be the best financial choice.

For example, a hybrid sedan might depreciate slightly more than a petrol SUV, but the fuel savings could offset that difference within a few years. Always consider your driving habits and local fuel prices.

Safety and Practicality Considerations

SUVs are often perceived as safer due to their size and higher seating position, but they also have a higher rollover risk compared to sedans. Modern SUVs have electronic stability control and advanced airbags, which mitigate this. If safety is your priority, check crash test ratings from organizations like IIHS and Euro NCAP. A vehicle with top safety ratings tends to hold value better because families seek them out.

Practicality also plays a role: SUVs offer more cargo space and easier entry, which appeals to aging buyers and families. That broad appeal supports used prices.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do SUVs hold their value better than pickup trucks?

Generally, pickup trucks like the Toyota Tacoma or Ford F-150 hold value better than most SUVs because of strong demand for used trucks in construction and rural areas. However, compact SUVs often match or beat full-size trucks in percentage retained, especially if the truck has high mileage.

Is it better to buy a used SUV or a new sedan for resale?

If you plan to sell in 3-5 years, a used SUV that’s already taken its biggest depreciation hit may be safer. A new sedan will lose 20-30% in the first year alone. But if you want a new car, a popular SUV model with a good reputation will likely retain more value than a new sedan.

How much does mileage affect SUV value?

Mileage is a major factor. A 3-year-old SUV with 30,000 miles might be worth 10-15% more than one with 60,000 miles. The average driver puts about 12,000 miles per year, so aim for that or less.

Do electric SUVs depreciate faster than petrol SUVs?

Yes, currently electric SUVs tend to depreciate faster because battery technology improves quickly and buyers worry about battery degradation. However, as battery prices drop and range improves, this gap may narrow. Some used electric SUVs are bargains precisely because of this depreciation.

What is the best time to sell an SUV to maximize value?

Typically, selling before 5 years or 60,000 miles is ideal. After that, depreciation slows but maintenance costs rise, and buyers become more cautious. Also, selling in spring or summer when families are shopping for road trips can get a slightly better price.

Does color affect SUV resale value?

Yes, but modestly. Neutral colors like white, black, silver, and gray are the safest. Bright colors like orange or yellow can reduce the pool of buyers, sometimes by 5% or more, especially on SUVs which are often bought for family use.

Related

Formula used
in t | Purchase price | USD | 35000 | 0
in a | Age | years | 3 | 0
out v | Estimated value | USD | t * (0.85 - 0.10 * a) | 0

Each line is one input (in, sel, list) or one result (out: label, unit, formula, decimals). How the calculators work

Method: the standard formula for this calculation, rounded as each result states. See how the calculators work or report an error.