ThisCalculator

Everyday

Safety Bubble Detectors: When Does a Robot Need a Scanner?

Updated · Standard formula, shown below

Stopping distance 0.62 m
Response time
80 ms
You entered
Robot speed
1.5 m/s
You entered
Minimum distance
0.5 m
You entered

Safety bubble detectors, also known as safety laser scanners, create a two-dimensional protective zone around a robot or automated vehicle. You need a scanner when the robot must detect people or obstacles entering a defined area from multiple directions, without physical contact, and stop or slow down before a collision. This article explains how these devices work, when they are required, and how they compare to other safety sensors.

Formula

The stopping distance for a robot with a safety scanner is calculated as:

Stopping distance (m) = Robot speed (m/s) × (Response time (ms) / 1000) + Minimum distance (m)

Where:

  • Robot speed (v) – the maximum speed of the robot in meters per second.
  • Response time (t) – the time it takes for the scanner to detect an object and send a stop signal, in milliseconds.
  • Minimum distance (d) – the extra safety margin required by standards, in meters.

The result is the minimum distance the scanner must be placed ahead of the robot to ensure it stops before hitting a person.

Worked Example

Using the default values from the calculator:

  • Robot speed = 1.5 m/s
  • Response time = 80 ms
  • Minimum distance = 0.5 m

First, convert response time to seconds: 80 ms ÷ 1000 = 0.08 s

Then calculate the distance traveled during response: 1.5 m/s × 0.08 s = 0.12 m

Add the minimum distance: 0.12 m + 0.5 m = 0.62 m

The stopping distance is 0.62 meters.

What Is a Safety Bubble Detector?

A safety laser scanner is a device that emits a rotating infrared beam and measures the time it takes for the beam to reflect off an object. It creates a two-dimensional “bubble” around the robot, which can be configured with different warning and safety zones. When an object enters the safety zone, the scanner sends a signal to the robot controller to stop or reduce speed.

Unlike simple light curtains or pressure mats, a scanner covers a 270-degree field of view and can be programmed with multiple zones, making it ideal for mobile robots and automated guided vehicles (AGVs) that move in open areas.

When Does a Robot Need a Scanner?

You need a safety laser scanner when the robot operates in an area where people can approach from any direction and a physical guard is not practical. Common situations include:

  • Mobile robots – AGVs, forklifts, and delivery robots that move through warehouses or factories.
  • Collaborative robots – when the robot shares a workspace with humans but needs to operate at higher speeds when no one is near.
  • Large work envelopes – when the robot’s reach is too large for a simple light curtain to cover.
  • Frequent access – when operators need to enter the robot’s area regularly, and a fixed fence would be impractical.

If the robot is stationary and the hazardous area is well-defined, a light curtain or safety mat may be sufficient. But if the robot moves or the danger zone changes, a scanner is the standard choice.

How to Choose the Right Scanner

Selecting a safety laser scanner involves several factors:

  • Protective field range – the maximum distance at which the scanner can detect an object. Typical ranges are 4 to 8 meters.
  • Scanning angle – most scanners cover 270 degrees, but some offer 190 or 360 degrees.
  • Response time – the time between detection and signal output. Faster is safer but may reduce range.
  • Resolution – the minimum object size that can be reliably detected. A smaller resolution detects thinner objects but may be more sensitive to dust.
  • Environmental rating – IP65 or higher for dusty or wet environments.

You must also ensure the scanner meets relevant safety standards such as ISO 13849 or IEC 61508, which define performance levels and safety integrity levels.

Common Problems and Misconceptions

One common misconception is that a safety scanner can replace all physical guards. In practice, scanners are used to supplement guards, not replace them. They are not effective against objects that are low to the ground (like a person’s foot) if the mounting height is too high.

Another issue is incorrect zone configuration. If the safety zone is too small, the robot may not stop in time. If it is too large, the robot may stop unnecessarily, reducing productivity. Regular testing and validation are required to ensure the scanner still detects objects correctly.

Dust, dirt, and fog can reduce detection range. Some scanners have built-in contamination warnings, but regular cleaning is essential.

Scanner vs. Other Safety Sensors

Here is a quick comparison:

  • Light curtains – detect objects crossing a single plane. They are cheaper and faster but only cover a straight line.
  • Safety mats – detect pressure on a floor area. They are simple but require physical contact and can be damaged by heavy loads.
  • Ultrasonic sensors – detect objects using sound waves. They are low-cost but less reliable in noisy or dusty environments.
  • Vision systems – use cameras to detect people. They offer more flexibility but require more processing power and can be affected by lighting.

Safety laser scanners offer the best balance of area coverage, speed, and reliability for moving robots.

Cost and Safety Considerations

Safety laser scanners are more expensive than simple sensors, typically ranging from a few hundred to several thousand dollars depending on range and features. However, they are often cheaper than installing physical fencing and gates, especially in flexible manufacturing setups.

When installing a scanner, you must consider the mounting height and angle to ensure the protective field covers the entire hazardous area. The scanner should be positioned so that a person cannot stand between the scanner and the robot without being detected. Regular maintenance and periodic checks are required to maintain safety certification.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can a safety scanner detect a person lying on the floor?
Most scanners are mounted at a height of 20-30 cm and can detect a person lying down if the protective field is configured correctly. However, the scanner only sees a 2D plane, so objects below or above that plane are not detected.

What is the difference between a warning zone and a safety zone?
A warning zone triggers a signal to slow the robot or alert the operator, but does not stop it. A safety zone stops the robot immediately. Both zones are defined in the scanner’s configuration software.

How often should a safety scanner be tested?
Standards recommend a functional test at the start of each shift, and a full validation after any changes to the robot or its environment. The manufacturer’s manual usually provides specific intervals.

Can a scanner be used outdoors?
Yes, but you need a model with an IP rating suitable for rain and dust, and you must account for sunlight interference. Some scanners have special filters for outdoor use.

Do I need a scanner if my robot is behind a fence?
No, if the fence prevents access to the hazardous area, a scanner is not necessary. Scanners are for areas where people can enter, such as loading zones or shared workspaces.

Related

Formula used
in t | Response time | ms | 80 | 0
in v | Robot speed | m/s | 1.5 | 0
in d | Minimum distance | m | 0.5 | 0
out stop | Stopping distance | m | v * (t / 1000) + d | 2

Each line is one input (in, sel, list) or one result (out: label, unit, formula, decimals). How the calculators work

Method: the standard formula for this calculation, rounded as each result states. See how the calculators work or report an error.