Cortana and Windows Search Split in 19H1
Yes, Microsoft split Cortana and Windows Search in Windows 10 19H1 (version 1903). The two features, previously intertwined in the taskbar search box, were separated into distinct experiences: Windows Search now handles local and web file lookups, while Cortana focuses on voice commands and personal assistant tasks.
Background: Why They Were Combined
When Windows 10 launched in 2015, Microsoft integrated Cortana directly into the taskbar search box. Typing a query would invoke both local file search and Cortana’s web results, and voice activation was always available. This design aimed to make Cortana the primary entry point for all searches, but it created confusion: users often didn’t know whether a query would return local files, web results, or both. It also meant that disabling Cortana (via Group Policy or registry) would break the search box entirely, forcing users to rely on File Explorer for local searches.
What Changed in 19H1
Starting with Windows 10 version 1903 (May 2019 update), Microsoft separated the two features. The taskbar search box now exclusively handles Windows Search—local files, settings, and web results via Bing—while Cortana is a separate app that can be launched by clicking the Cortana icon or pressing Win+C. This separation was part of a broader shift to make Cortana more like a standalone assistant, similar to mobile voice assistants, rather than a search-box overlay.
How the Separation Works
After the update, the search box on the taskbar behaves like a classic search bar. Typing a query shows local results (apps, documents, settings) and optionally web results from Bing. Cortana, on the other hand, is a dedicated app with its own window. You can still use voice commands like “Hey Cortana” to open apps or set reminders, but the assistant no longer intercepts every typed search. The two features share some backend services (e.g., Bing web search), but they are now independent in terms of UI and settings.
How to Choose Between Them
For most users, the split means you should use the search box for finding files and apps, and use Cortana for voice commands and personal assistant tasks. If you want to disable Cortana entirely, you can now do so without losing local search functionality. To disable Cortana, you can use Group Policy (Computer Configuration > Administrative Templates > Windows Components > Search > Allow Cortana) or simply right-click the Cortana icon and unpin it from the taskbar. The search box remains fully functional.
Common Problems and Misconceptions
A common misconception is that the split removed web search from the taskbar. In fact, web results still appear in the search box, but you can turn them off by setting the search box to “Classic” mode (via Settings > Search > Permissions & History). Another issue users face is that after the update, the search box may not show web results if Cortana is disabled. This is because web results are tied to Bing, and some settings may need to be re-enabled. If search stops working after the update, restarting the SearchUI.exe process or running the Search and Indexing troubleshooter usually fixes it.
Comparison: Before and After 19H1
- Before: Single search box, Cortana integrated, disabling Cortana broke search.
- After: Separate search box and Cortana app, disabling Cortana leaves search intact.
- Before: Voice commands always available in search box.
- After: Voice commands only in Cortana app or via “Hey Cortana”.
- Before: Web results and local results mixed in one list.
- After: Web results can be toggled independently.
Costs and Safety Considerations
There is no cost to using either feature; both are included with Windows 10. From a privacy standpoint, the separation gives you more control. You can disable web search in the search box (Settings > Search > Permissions & History > Turn off web results) and turn off Cortana’s voice activation (Settings > Cortana > Talk to Cortana). This reduces the data sent to Microsoft. However, if you use Cortana, be aware that it may collect location, voice, and browsing data to personalize responses. You can review and delete this data via the Microsoft privacy dashboard.
Alternatives to the Built-in Features
If you find the split confusing or want more control, third-party launchers like Keypirinha or Listary offer fast local file search without web integration. For voice assistants, you can use Windows’ built-in dictation (Win+H) for speech-to-text, or rely on your smartphone’s assistant. But for most users, the default split is sufficient: use the search box for files and settings, and Cortana only if you actually use voice commands.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I still use voice commands with the search box?
No, voice commands are now exclusive to the Cortana app. The search box only accepts typed input.
Will disabling Cortana break my search box?
No, that was the main point of the split. You can disable Cortana via Group Policy or by unpinning it, and the search box will still work for local and web searches.
How do I get web results back in the search box?
Go to Settings > Search > Permissions & History and ensure “Show web results” is enabled. If it’s already on, try toggling it off and on, or restart the SearchUI.exe process.
Does the split affect Windows 10 versions after 1903?
Yes, the separation persists in later versions, including 20H1 and 21H2. Microsoft has continued to refine Cortana as a standalone app, and the search box remains separate.
Why did Microsoft make this change?
To improve clarity and performance. Combining the two made search less predictable, and separating them allowed Microsoft to update Cortana independently and let users disable it without losing core search functionality.
Related
Method: the standard formula for this calculation, rounded as each result states. See how the calculators work or report an error.