Mass Effect Andromeda Worth Playing After the Trilogy?
Yes, Mass Effect: Andromeda is worth playing after the original trilogy, but with clear expectations: it offers a more open, exploration-focused experience with solid combat and a fresh story, yet it lacks the narrative depth, character polish, and emotional weight of the trilogy. If you can accept it as a spin-off rather than a true sequel, you’ll find an enjoyable sci-fi RPG that goes on sale frequently.
Background: Where Andromeda Fits in the Timeline
Mass Effect: Andromeda (released March 2017) takes place roughly 600 years after the events of Mass Effect 3, in a different galaxy. The game follows the Andromeda Initiative—a multi-species expedition sent to the Heleus Cluster before the Reaper war. You play as Ryder (pathfinder), tasked with finding new home worlds for the ark ships. The game deliberately avoids direct connections to the trilogy: the Milky Way characters are gone, the Reapers are absent, and the narrative is self-contained. This was a conscious design choice to allow new players to jump in, but it also means you won’t get closure for Shepard’s story or see familiar faces beyond a few cameos.
How It Works: Core Gameplay Differences
Andromeda shifts the series from linear, mission-based storytelling to a semi-open world structure. You explore planets in the Nomad (a six-wheeled vehicle), scan for resources, and activate monoliths to make worlds habitable. The core gameplay loop is:
- Exploration: Each planet has a large map with side quests, enemy camps, and puzzles. The Remnant vaults are the main dungeon-like areas.
- Combat: The combat is the game’s strongest aspect—it’s faster and more fluid than the trilogy, with a jetpack (jump-jet) that allows vertical movement, and profiles that let you switch between classes (Soldier, Adept, etc.) on the fly.
- Dialogue: The dialogue wheel returns, but Ryder’s tone is more casual and less authoritative than Shepard’s. There are no paragon/renegade points; instead, you choose from four emotional responses (emotional, logical, casual, professional).
- Crafting and upgrades: You research and develop weapons, armor, and augmentations using resources gathered from planets.
How to Choose: Should You Play It?
Decide based on what you value in a Mass Effect game:
- Play it if you enjoy exploration, combat mechanics, and a lighter tone. If you like games like Dragon Age: Inquisition or The Witcher 3’s open-world structure, you’ll likely enjoy Andromeda.
- Skip it if you’re looking for a deep, character-driven narrative with meaningful choices and a tight, emotional story. The trilogy’s companions are more memorable, and the main plot twists are predictable.
- Consider it if you’re a completionist—there’s a lot of content, but much of it is fetch quests. The game can take 80+ hours to fully complete.
Common Problems: Bugs, Animations, and Pacing
Andromeda launched with a notorious set of bugs and animation issues, which were widely mocked online (e.g., the “My face is tired” line). Most of these were patched in the first few months, but some remain, especially on PC. The pacing is also uneven: the first few hours are slow, and the game only opens up after you reach the first major planet (Eos). The side quests are often repetitive, and the “scan everything” mechanic can feel tedious. The multiplayer mode, however, is still active and fun, though not as popular as the trilogy’s.
Comparisons: Andromeda vs. the Trilogy
Here’s a quick comparison to help you set expectations:
- Story: The trilogy is a space opera with high stakes (Reapers, galaxy-ending threat). Andromeda’s story is more personal and smaller-scale—you’re dealing with a hostile alien race (the Kett) and the aftermath of a failed initiative.
- Characters: The trilogy’s companions (Garrus, Tali, Liara, etc.) are iconic. Andromeda’s crew (Drack, Jaal, Vetra, etc.) are decent but not as memorable. The romance options are less developed.
- Choices: The trilogy’s choices carry over between games and have major consequences. Andromeda’s choices are mostly isolated to the game itself, and the ending is determined by your “viability” score on planets.
- Visuals and performance: Andromeda is more modern, with better graphics and a more detailed world, but the trilogy’s remastered version (Legendary Edition) holds up well.
Costs and Availability
Andromeda is often discounted to under $10 on PC (Steam, EA app) and console. The full price is $40, but you can usually find it for $5–$15 during sales. The game is included in EA Play and Xbox Game Pass Ultimate, so if you already subscribe, you can play it at no extra cost. The DLC (which was planned) was cancelled, so there’s no significant expansion—what you see is what you get.
Safety and Technical Notes
No major safety concerns—it’s a single-player game with no microtransactions (the multiplayer has loot boxes, but they’re cosmetic and earnable). On PC, the game is stable on modern systems, but you may need to adjust settings to avoid crashes. There are mods that fix bugs and improve the experience (e.g., the “Andromeda Fixpack” on Nexus Mods). On console, the game runs at 30 FPS on base models, but the Xbox One X and PS4 Pro versions have a performance mode.
Alternatives: What to Play Instead
If you’re not sold on Andromeda, here are some alternatives that scratch a similar itch:
- Mass Effect Legendary Edition: The remastered trilogy with all DLC. If you haven’t played the original games in years, this is the definitive way to revisit them.
- Dragon Age: Inquisition: Same developer, similar open-world structure, but with a more engaging story and characters.
- The Outer Worlds: A shorter, more humorous sci-fi RPG with a focus on choice and dialogue.
- Starfield: If you want a massive space exploration game with more depth, though it’s more recent and heavier on systems.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Mass Effect Andromeda a direct sequel to the trilogy? No. It’s a spin-off set 600 years later in a different galaxy. You don’t need to have played the trilogy to understand it, but knowing the lore helps.
Do choices from the trilogy affect Andromeda? No. There’s no save import, and the game ignores the endings of Mass Effect 3. It’s a fresh start.
Is the game still buggy? Most major bugs were patched, but you may encounter minor glitches. The animation issues are largely fixed, but some facial animations remain stiff.
How long is Mass Effect Andromeda? The main story takes about 20-25 hours. With side content, it can take 60-80 hours to complete everything.
Can I play Andromeda without playing the trilogy? Yes, the game is designed to be a jumping-on point. You’ll miss some references, but the story is self-contained.
Is the multiplayer worth playing? The co-op multiplayer is fun and similar to Mass Effect 3’s, but the player base is smaller. It’s best played with friends.
Related
Method: the standard formula for this calculation, rounded as each result states. See how the calculators work or report an error.