Marathon vs Arc Raiders: Key Differences
Marathon and Arc Raiders are both upcoming extraction shooters, but they differ fundamentally in setting, tone, and core gameplay loop. Marathon is a sci-fi PvP-focused extraction shooter set in a single persistent universe, while Arc Raiders is a co-op PvE third-person shooter where you fight alien machines. This article breaks down what each game actually is, how they play, and which one might suit you better.
Background: What Are These Games?
Marathon is a revival of Bungie’s 1994 sci-fi FPS franchise, announced in 2023. It is being developed by Bungie (the studio behind Destiny and Halo) and is set in the same universe as the original Marathon games, though it is not a direct sequel. The game is a PvP-focused extraction shooter, meaning players enter a hostile zone, collect loot, and try to escape while fighting other players and AI enemies. It has no single-player campaign and is designed as a live-service game.
Arc Raiders is a co-op PvE third-person shooter developed by Embark Studios (founded by ex-DICE developers). It was originally announced in 2021 as a PvE game, but later pivoted to include PvPvE elements, though the core is still cooperative play against AI-controlled machines. The game is set on a post-apocalyptic Earth where robotic machines called ARC have taken over. Players work together in squads to complete missions, scavenge resources, and survive.
Core Gameplay: Extraction vs. Co-op Missions
The biggest difference is the gameplay loop. Marathon is an extraction shooter: you drop into a map, gather gear and resources, and must extract at designated points while avoiding other players. Death is permanent—you lose everything you brought in. This creates high-stakes tension and player-versus-player encounters.
Arc Raiders, by contrast, is primarily cooperative. You and your squad take on missions against AI-controlled enemies, similar to games like Left 4 Dead or Warhammer: Vermintide. There is no permanent loss of gear; you simply re-enter a mission if you fail. The game also features a hub area where you can upgrade your character and weapons between missions.
Setting and Tone
Marathon is set in a far-future sci-fi universe with a mysterious AI called WANDA, a lost colony ship, and a strange alien race. The tone is serious, mysterious, and lore-heavy, in the style of Bungie’s other works. The game is played from a first-person perspective.
Arc Raiders is set on a near-future Earth after a war with alien machines. The tone is more grounded and gritty, with a focus on survival and human resistance. It is played from a third-person perspective, which affects how you see your character and the world around you.
Platforms and Release Status
Both games are currently in development and have not been released. Marathon is planned for PC, PlayStation 5, and Xbox Series X|S, but no release date has been announced. Arc Raiders is also planned for PC, PS5, and Xbox Series X|S, with a release date still unconfirmed. Both games will be available on multiple platforms, but cross-play and cross-progression details have not been fully detailed.
How to Choose: Which One Is for You?
Your choice depends on your preferred playstyle:
- If you enjoy PvP tension and high-stakes risk/reward: Marathon is the clear choice. Extraction shooters like Escape from Tarkov and Hunt: Showdown appeal to players who like the adrenaline of fighting real opponents and the fear of losing gear.
- If you prefer cooperative teamwork without PvP stress: Arc Raiders is more your style. It offers a more relaxed, mission-based experience where you can play with friends without the constant threat of player ambushes.
- If you like deep lore and sci-fi narratives: Marathon’s universe is rich with Bungie’s signature storytelling, but note that it is an online multiplayer game, so the story is delivered through environmental details and lore entries, not a campaign.
- If you want a game you can play solo: Arc Raiders may be more accessible, as co-op games often have matchmaking and are less punishing for solo players. Marathon, like most extraction shooters, is heavily PvP-oriented and may be brutal for solo players.
Common Misconceptions
One common misconception is that Marathon is a remake of the original 1994 game. It is not. It is a new game set in the same universe, with new characters and a new story. Another misconception is that Arc Raiders is a PvP game like Escape from Tarkov. While it has some PvPvE elements, the core is cooperative, and the developers have emphasized that it is primarily a PvE experience.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Marathon free to play? Bungie has not announced a pricing model yet. Many extraction shooters are premium titles, but some are free-to-play with microtransactions. We’ll have to wait for an official announcement.
Can I play Arc Raiders solo? Yes, you can play solo, but the game is designed for co-op. You’ll likely have a harder time alone, but it’s possible.
Which game has better graphics? Both use modern engines (Marathon uses a custom engine, Arc Raiders uses Unreal Engine 5). It’s too early to compare, and graphics are subjective.
Will there be cross-play? Both games have not confirmed cross-play, but it’s common in modern multiplayer games. Check official announcements closer to release.
Are there microtransactions? Marathon is likely to have cosmetic microtransactions, as Bungie has done with Destiny. Arc Raiders may also have them, but nothing is confirmed.
Related
Method: the standard formula for this calculation, rounded as each result states. See how the calculators work or report an error.