MX Creative Keypad vs Stream Deck: Which Wins?
The Logitech MX Creative Keypad and the Elgato Stream Deck are both macro keypads, but they serve different primary purposes. The Stream Deck is the more versatile and widely compatible option for general productivity and streaming, while the MX Creative Keypad offers deeper integration with Adobe Creative Cloud apps. For most users, the Stream Deck is the better productivity controller due to its broader software support and customizable display keys.
Background: Two Approaches to Macro Keypads
Macro keypads have been around for decades, but the Elgato Stream Deck, launched in 2017, popularized the modern concept: a grid of LCD keys that change their labels based on context. It was designed for streamers to switch scenes, mute mics, and trigger alerts, but its software (Stream Deck app) allows mapping any key to keyboard shortcuts, system commands, or third-party integrations. The Logitech MX Creative Keypad, released in 2023, is a collaboration with Adobe, aimed squarely at creative professionals who live in Photoshop, Premiere Pro, After Effects, and other Adobe apps. It features a dial and a row of buttons, with a small display that shows contextual information. While the Stream Deck is a general-purpose tool, the MX Creative Keypad is optimized for a specific workflow.
How Each Device Works
The Stream Deck uses a grid of 6, 15, or 32 LCD keys (depending on model). Each key can be assigned an action—like a hotkey, a text snippet, or a multi-step macro—and the key’s display updates to show a custom icon or label. The software runs on Windows and macOS, and it can also control smart home devices, OBS Studio, and hundreds of other apps via plugins. The MX Creative Keypad, in contrast, has a row of nine buttons and a large dial. It connects via Bluetooth or USB-C and works with Logitech’s Options+ software. Its standout feature is the Adobe Creative Cloud integration: it can automatically show context-sensitive controls for the active Adobe app, such as brush size in Photoshop or timeline zoom in Premiere Pro. The dial can be used for scrubbing, zooming, or adjusting values, and the buttons can be customized, but they are not LCD keys—they have fixed labels.
Key Differences in Customization and Flexibility
The Stream Deck’s LCD keys give it a huge advantage in customization. You can create folders, pages, and profiles, and each key can change its appearance based on the app in focus. For example, you can have a profile for Excel with keys for formatting, and another for Chrome with keys for tab management. The MX Creative Keypad’s buttons are static, so you must remember what each button does for each app, though the small display shows the current function of the dial and a few buttons. The Stream Deck also has a much larger library of community-made plugins and profiles, covering everything from Discord to Spotify to professional software like DaVinci Resolve. The MX Creative Keypad’s integration with Adobe is deeper, but it is limited to Adobe apps—outside of those, it is essentially a basic macro pad with a dial.
Physical Design and Ergonomics
The Stream Deck (15-key version) is a compact, flat device that sits on your desk. Its keys are tactile and clicky, and the LCD screen is bright and easy to read. The MX Creative Keypad has a more sculpted, angled design with a large aluminum dial and nine rubberized buttons. It is designed to sit to the left of a keyboard, and the dial is comfortable to use for extended periods. The keypad’s build quality is excellent, with a premium feel. The Stream Deck’s keys are more satisfying to press, but the MX Creative Keypad’s dial is a unique input that the Stream Deck lacks. If you do a lot of scrubbing or value adjusting (like in audio or video editing), the dial is a significant advantage.
Software and Compatibility
The Stream Deck software is mature, stable, and available for Windows and macOS. It supports plugins, and the SDK is open, so developers create integrations for almost any app. The MX Creative Keypad uses Logitech Options+, which is also available for both platforms, but its Adobe integration requires the Adobe Creative Cloud desktop app and works best with the latest versions of Adobe software. Options+ is generally reliable, but it has fewer third-party integrations than the Stream Deck. For non-Adobe apps, the MX Creative Keypad can still send keystrokes and launch apps, but you lose the context-sensitive magic. The Stream Deck, on the other hand, works with virtually any app that supports keyboard shortcuts, which is all of them.
Common Problems and Misconceptions
A common misconception is that the MX Creative Keypad is just a Stream Deck clone with a dial. In reality, it is a purpose-built tool for Adobe users, and its value outside that ecosystem is limited. A frequent issue with the Stream Deck is that some plugins stop working after software updates, but this is usually fixed quickly. With the MX Creative Keypad, users sometimes report that the Adobe integration doesn’t recognize the active app if the app is not installed in the default location, or if the Creative Cloud app is not running. Both devices can have connectivity issues when used with USB hubs, so it’s best to plug them directly into the computer.
How to Choose Between Them
Consider your primary software and workflow:
- If you use Adobe Creative Cloud apps daily (Photoshop, Premiere Pro, After Effects, Lightroom), the MX Creative Keypad offers deep, contextual controls that can speed up your editing significantly. The dial is especially useful for timeline scrubbing and brush size adjustment.
- If you use a variety of apps (browsers, office suites, coding, streaming, or gaming), the Stream Deck is the better choice because of its universal compatibility and customizable LCD keys.
- If you are a streamer, the Stream Deck is the industry standard, with native OBS Studio integration and countless plugins for alerts, chat, and music.
- If you prefer tactile buttons with visual feedback, the Stream Deck’s LCD keys are superior. If you want a physical dial and don’t mind static labels, the MX Creative Keypad is more ergonomic for certain tasks.
Also consider the price: the Stream Deck (15-key) and the MX Creative Keypad are in a similar price range, but the Stream Deck has cheaper 6-key and more expensive 32-key variants, so you can match your budget and needs.
Cost and Value
Both devices are premium accessories, typically priced above $100. The Stream Deck offers more value for most users because it is a general-purpose tool that can be used for years across different jobs and hobbies. The MX Creative Keypad’s value is tied to your use of Adobe software. If you are a professional video editor or graphic designer, the time savings from the dial and contextual controls can justify the cost. For a casual user, the Stream Deck is a safer investment.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can the MX Creative Keypad work without Adobe software? Yes, it can be used as a basic macro keypad with Logitech Options+, but you lose the context-sensitive features. The dial can still be programmed to adjust volume or zoom, and the buttons can trigger shortcuts.
Does the Stream Deck work with Mac and Windows? Yes, the Stream Deck software is available for both macOS and Windows, and the device works with both. You can even use it with an iPad via a companion app, though functionality is limited.
Can I use the Stream Deck for photo editing? Absolutely. You can map keys to actions in Photoshop or Lightroom, such as brush size, zoom, or specific filters. However, it lacks the dial, so you’ll have to use keyboard shortcuts for value adjustments.
Is the MX Creative Keypad worth it for Premiere Pro? For heavy Premiere Pro users, yes. The dial is great for scrubbing the timeline, and the contextual buttons change to show relevant tools, which can reduce menu digging.
Which has better build quality? Both are well-built. The MX Creative Keypad feels more premium due to its aluminum dial and rubberized surface, but the Stream Deck’s keys are more durable for repeated pressing.
Can I use both devices together? Yes, you can use them simultaneously. Many users pair a Stream Deck for general macros and an MX Creative Keypad for Adobe-specific tasks, though that is an expensive setup.
Related
Method: the standard formula for this calculation, rounded as each result states. See how the calculators work or report an error.