ThisCalculator

Everyday

Gravitational Lenses in Public Data: A How-To

Updated · Standard formula, shown below

Gravitational Lenses in Public Data: A How-To

This guide shows you how to find and explore gravitational lenses—massive objects that bend light from distant galaxies—using free, publicly available astronomical data. You’ll learn where to get the data, how to identify lens candidates, and how to use simple tools to confirm your findings. No prior experience with astronomy or coding is required, but basic familiarity with web browsers and spreadsheets will help.

What You’ll Need

  • A computer with internet access
  • A web browser (Chrome, Firefox, or Edge recommended)
  • Optional: A free account at the Legacy Survey or Aladin (not required for basic viewing)
  • Optional: A spreadsheet program (Excel, Google Sheets) for organizing candidates
  • Optional: Basic knowledge of astronomical coordinates (RA and Dec)

Step-by-Step

  1. Understand what a gravitational lens looks like. In images, a lens often appears as an arc or a ring of light around a foreground galaxy. The foreground galaxy is usually a massive elliptical galaxy (bright, round, red). The background galaxy is often blue and stretched into a curve. You’re looking for these distinctive shapes.
  2. Choose a data source. The best public datasets for finding lenses are:
    • Legacy Survey (DR10): High-resolution optical and infrared images covering most of the sky. Use the viewer to pan and zoom.
    • DESI Legacy Imaging Surveys: Same as above, but the viewer is the main tool.
    • Hubble Space Telescope (HST) archives: High-resolution images but limited sky coverage. Use the HLA.
    • SDSS (Sloan Digital Sky Survey): Good for wide-field, but lower resolution than the Legacy Survey.
  3. Start with known lens catalogs. To train your eye, look at confirmed lenses first. The Legacy Survey Lens Catalog lists thousands of candidates. Open a few and study their appearance.
  4. Pick a search area. Avoid the Milky Way’s plane (where stars crowd the view) and areas with lots of dust. Good regions are around the north and south galactic poles. The Legacy Survey viewer lets you enter coordinates; start with RA=150, Dec=0 (a random spot) and zoom out to see the field.
  5. Scan systematically. Use the Legacy Survey viewer in “optical” mode. Zoom to a level where galaxies are clearly visible (about 10–20 arcseconds across). Pan across the sky in a grid pattern, looking for the telltale arcs or rings. This is the most time-consuming step—expect to spend hours.
  6. Examine candidates in multiple bands. When you spot a possible lens, toggle between the g, r, and z bands (or use the color image). A real lens will show the same arc shape in all bands, though the color may differ. If the arc only appears in one band, it might be an artifact.
  7. Check the lens galaxy’s color. The foreground lensing galaxy is typically massive and red (old stars). Use the viewer’s photometry tool (if available) or the SDSS navigator to get the colors. A red galaxy with a blue arc around it is a strong lens candidate.
  8. Measure the Einstein radius. This is the angular radius of the ring/arc. In the Legacy Survey viewer, you can use the distance tool (click on the lens center, then on the arc). The Einstein radius is typically 1–3 arcseconds for galaxy-scale lenses.
  9. Cross-match with catalogs. Once you have a candidate, note its RA and Dec. Use the VizieR service to search for known objects at that position. If it’s already in a lens catalog, you’ve confirmed a known lens. If not, you may have found a new candidate!
  10. Document your findings. Record the coordinates, the appearance, and any notes. If you want to contribute to science, consider submitting your candidate to the Zooniverse or a professional survey team (though that’s beyond this guide).

Common Mistakes

  • Confusing spiral arms with lens arcs. Spiral galaxies can show blue arcs that are actually star-forming regions. Check if the arc is centered on a red, round galaxy—that’s the key.
  • Ignoring the redshift. A lens requires the background object to be far behind the foreground galaxy. Without spectra, you can’t be sure. But if the arc is much bluer than the central galaxy, it’s likely a background source.
  • Using too low a resolution. The Legacy Survey viewer defaults to a wide field; zoom in until individual galaxies are sharp. If you’re using SDSS images, they may be too blurry for small lenses.
  • Forgetting to check for artifacts. Diffraction spikes from bright stars, cosmic rays, and CCD artifacts can mimic arcs. Toggle between bands and look for consistency.
  • Assuming every ring is a lens. Some galaxies have ring-like structures (e.g., ring galaxies) that are not gravitational lenses. Check if the ring is a perfect circle around a central galaxy—lens rings are often partial arcs.

Tips

  • Start with known lenses. Spend at least an hour studying confirmed lenses before hunting for new ones. You’ll develop a visual intuition.
  • Use the color image mode. The Legacy Survey viewer’s color mode (grz composite) makes blue arcs stand out against red galaxies.
  • Work in a team. Divide a sky region among friends; each person scans a different part. This speeds up the search.
  • Use the “lens” overlay in the Legacy Survey viewer. It shows known lenses as markers, so you can avoid re-finding them and focus on new areas.
  • Take screenshots. Save images of your candidates for later review. You can use the viewer’s “share” button to get a persistent URL.
  • Be patient. Finding a lens is rare—most galaxies are not lenses. Expect to scan hundreds of galaxies before finding a good candidate.

Troubleshooting

  • I can’t see any arcs. Ensure you’re zoomed in enough. Try looking at a known lens (e.g., SDSS J0959+0200) to calibrate your eye. Also, check that your screen brightness is high enough.
  • The viewer is slow. Reduce the image resolution or use the “fast” mode. Close other tabs that use bandwidth.
  • I found a candidate but it’s not in any catalog. That’s exciting! It could be a new discovery. Verify it in multiple bands and note the coordinates. You can also use the Aladin tool to overlay other surveys (e.g., infrared from WISE) to see if the arc persists.
  • I’m not sure if my candidate is real. Post it on an astronomy forum (like the CosmoQuest forum) and ask for feedback. Other amateur astronomers can help.
  • The coordinates don’t match between surveys. Make sure you’re using the same epoch (J2000 is standard). If you’re using the Legacy Survey viewer, it uses J2000 by default.
  • I accidentally zoomed out too far and lost my place. Use the “home” button or re-enter your starting coordinates.

Frequently Asked Questions

  1. Do I need to know math or physics to find lenses? No, you only need visual pattern recognition. The physics is helpful for understanding, but not required for discovery.
  2. Can I find lenses in any telescope image? In principle, yes, but high-resolution images are best. The Legacy Survey is ideal because it covers a large area with good resolution.
  3. How long does it take to find one lens? For a beginner, it might take several hours of scanning. With practice, you can find one in a few hours if you’re lucky. Many amateurs have found new lenses.
  4. Are there any citizen science projects for lens hunting? Yes, the Zooniverse has hosted projects like “Space Warps” that specifically ask volunteers to find lenses. You can join those to contribute to real research.
  5. What if I find a lens that’s not in any catalog? That’s a potential discovery! You should document it carefully and contact a professional astronomer (via an observatory or university) to report it. They will likely follow up with spectroscopy.
  6. Can I use this method to find strong lenses (with multiple images)? Yes, the same visual techniques apply. Strong lenses often show multiple arcs or points around the central galaxy, which are easier to spot.

Related

Method: the standard formula for this calculation, rounded as each result states. See how the calculators work or report an error.