ThisCalculator

Everyday

Evaluating De-Extinction Projects: Claims & Impact

Updated · Standard formula, shown below

This guide helps you critically assess the claims and conservation impact of any de-extinction project, whether it’s reviving the woolly mammoth, the passenger pigeon, or the thylacine. You’ll learn what evidence to look for, how to interpret the numbers, and what questions to ask before accepting a project’s promises. No scientific background is required—just a willingness to check sources and think in terms of risks and trade-offs.

What You’ll Need

  • Access to the project’s official website, published papers, and press releases
  • A web browser to search for independent news coverage and scientific commentary
  • Basic spreadsheet software (optional, for comparing claims across sources)
  • A notepad or document to record your findings and questions

Step-by-Step

  1. Identify the core claim. Start by writing down exactly what the project says it will achieve. Look for specific, measurable claims—e.g., “we will have a living woolly mammoth calf by 2028” or “this will restore Arctic grasslands.” Avoid vague language like “we aim to bring back the species.” The more concrete the claim, the easier it is to evaluate.
  2. Check the species and the method. De-extinction can involve cloning (if intact cells exist), genetic engineering (editing the genome of a close living relative), or back-breeding (selective breeding for ancestral traits). Verify which method the project uses and whether it’s scientifically plausible for that species. For example, cloning requires a viable cell nucleus—impossible for species that went extinct centuries ago without preserved tissue.
  3. Look for published, peer-reviewed data. Search for the project’s research in scientific journals (e.g., Nature, Science, or specialized journals like Genome Biology). Press releases and websites are not enough. If the project has no peer-reviewed publications, treat its claims as unverified. Note the difference between a proof-of-concept (e.g., editing a gene in a lab) and a full organism.
  4. Examine the genetic evidence. For genetic engineering projects, ask: How many genes are being edited? What are those genes known to do? Is there evidence that the edits will produce the desired traits (e.g., cold tolerance, mammoth-like hair)? Look for data on the number of edits, the function of those genes, and any experimental validation. Be wary of claims that a few edits will “resurrect” a species—genomes are complex.
  5. Assess the timeline and feasibility. Compare the project’s stated timeline with the current stage of research. If they’re still editing cells in a lab, a calf in 5 years is extremely optimistic. Look for realistic milestones (e.g., creating a viable embryo, then a pregnancy, then a live birth). Check if the project has achieved any of these milestones yet.
  6. Evaluate the conservation impact claim. This is the most important step. Ask: What is the stated ecological benefit? For example, the woolly mammoth project claims that reintroducing mammoths to the Arctic could slow permafrost thaw by trampling snow and allowing cold air to penetrate. To evaluate this, look for: (a) a clear mechanism (how does the animal change the ecosystem?), (b) evidence that this mechanism works (e.g., studies on modern elephants or bison in similar environments), and (c) a realistic scale (how many animals would be needed to affect a meaningful area?).
  7. Check the animal welfare and ethics. De-extinction involves creating sentient beings. Look for information on how animals will be housed, cared for, and monitored. Are there plans for veterinary care, social needs, and potential suffering? A project that ignores welfare is a red flag. Also consider the ethics of using a surrogate mother from a closely related species—what happens if the pregnancy fails or the offspring has health issues?
  8. Compare with alternative conservation efforts. Ask: Could the money and effort be better spent on saving existing species? Look for cost estimates (often in the millions) and compare with the cost of, say, protecting habitat or breeding programs for endangered species. A de-extinction project should justify its cost relative to other conservation priorities.
  9. Look for independent assessments. Search for opinions from scientists not affiliated with the project. Read critiques and rebuttals. Look for consensus or lack thereof. Be wary of projects that dismiss all critics as “naysayers” without engaging with the substance.
  10. Check the funding and conflicts of interest. Who is funding the project? If it’s a private company, what are their motives? Look for any financial ties that might bias claims. Transparency about funding is a good sign.
  11. Summarize your findings. Create a simple table with columns: Claim, Evidence, Strength (Strong/Weak/None), and Notes. Rate each claim based on the evidence you found. Then form an overall judgment: Is the project’s science sound? Is the conservation impact plausible? Is it worth the cost and risk?

Common Mistakes

  • Confusing “genetically engineered” with “resurrected.” A hybrid elephant-mammoth is not a mammoth. It’s a new organism. The project may be valuable, but it’s not de-extinction in the true sense.
  • Overlooking the difference between a lab result and a living animal. Creating edited cells is a far cry from a healthy, reproducing population.
  • Accepting press release language at face value. Phrases like “breakthrough” or “world-first” are marketing, not science.
  • Ignoring the scale problem. Even if you can create one animal, you need a viable population (hundreds to thousands) to have any ecological effect. That’s rarely discussed.
  • Not considering the surrogate species. The welfare of surrogate mothers (e.g., elephants) is often overlooked. What happens to them if the pregnancy fails?

Tips

  • Use Google Scholar to find peer-reviewed papers. Search for the project name plus “genome” or “conservation.”
  • Look for the project’s own “white papers” or “technical reports” that detail methods and data.
  • Follow the scientists on Twitter or LinkedIn—they often share honest updates and respond to questions.
  • Check if the project has published a “conservation impact assessment” or similar document. If not, ask them why.
  • Remember that de-extinction is a long-term gamble. Even if it works, the impact may take decades to materialize. Be patient and skeptical.

Troubleshooting

What if the project has no peer-reviewed papers? That doesn’t automatically mean it’s fake, but it means you should be extra cautious. Look for preprints (e.g., on bioRxiv) and see if they’ve been criticized. If nothing is available, treat all claims as unverified.

What if the conservation impact seems plausible but the timeline is absurd? Focus on the science, not the hype. A project can have good science but unrealistic timelines. Evaluate the science separately from the marketing.

What if you can’t find independent assessments? Try searching for the project name plus “critique” or “controversy.” If you find nothing, that’s suspicious—most high-profile projects attract comment. You can also reach out to experts in the field via email; many are happy to share their views.

What if the project is secretive about its methods? That’s a red flag. Science requires transparency. If they won’t share details, they can’t be independently verified.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can we actually bring back an extinct species? Not yet. For species with no living cells (like dinosaurs), it’s impossible. For recently extinct species with preserved tissue (like the thylacine), cloning might be possible, but it’s extremely difficult. Genetic engineering can create a hybrid, but not a true clone.

Is de-extinction worth the cost? That’s a value judgment. Some argue that the money could save many living species. Others say the technology has spin-off benefits. Look at the cost estimates and decide for yourself.

What is the “de-extinction” of the woolly mammoth? The most prominent project is by Colossal Biosciences, which aims to create an elephant-mammoth hybrid by editing the Asian elephant genome. They claim it could help restore Arctic grasslands and slow permafrost thaw.

How many animals would be needed to have an ecological impact? For the mammoth steppe, it would likely require thousands of animals over a vast area. That’s far beyond current plans. For smaller species, the number might be lower, but still substantial.

Are there any ethical guidelines for de-extinction? The IUCN has published guidelines that emphasize the welfare of individual animals, the importance of a clear conservation benefit, and the need for public engagement. Check if the project follows these.

What should I do if I find a project’s claims are exaggerated? Share your findings. Write a blog post, contact journalists, or simply discuss it with others. Informed public skepticism is a healthy check on hype.

Related

Method: the standard formula for this calculation, rounded as each result states. See how the calculators work or report an error.