ThisCalculator

Everyday

How to Choose a Game of the Year Winner for Your Gaming Group

Updated · Standard formula, shown below

Choosing a Game of the Year for your gaming group is a fun way to celebrate the year you’ve spent together and highlight the titles everyone enjoyed most. This guide walks you through a fair, transparent voting process that works for any group size—from a handful of friends to a larger community. You’ll define categories, set up a nomination phase, run a vote, and announce the winner in a way that feels inclusive and exciting.

What You’ll Need

  • A list of games your group played this year (from your play history, a shared spreadsheet, or a service like BoardGameGeek or Steam).
  • A communication channel where everyone can participate (group chat, Discord, email, or a simple poll tool).
  • A way to collect votes—this can be as simple as a message thread or as structured as a Google Form or polling website.
  • A clear timeline (e.g., nominations open for one week, voting for another).
  • Someone to act as the moderator/organizer (can rotate each year).

Step-by-Step

  1. Define the scope of “this year.” Decide whether you’re considering games released in the calendar year, or games your group first played this year. For most groups, “games we played for the first time this year” works best—it avoids arguments about release dates and includes older titles you just discovered.
  2. Set the categories. At minimum, have an overall “Game of the Year” category. Add a few more if your group enjoys variety, such as “Best Cooperative Game,” “Best Competitive Game,” “Best Party Game,” or “Most Surprising Game.” Keep the list to 3–5 categories so voting doesn’t feel like a chore.
  3. Create a master list of eligible games. Ask everyone to submit the titles they played this year (with the group). Combine these into a single list, removing duplicates. If you have a large group, you might set a minimum play count (e.g., at least 3 plays) to ensure the game actually got time at the table.
  4. Open nominations. For each category, ask each person to nominate 1–3 games from the master list. You can do this via a simple poll or a shared document. Encourage people to nominate games they genuinely want to win, not just ones they think are popular.
  5. Compile the nominees. Count nominations and keep the top 3–5 games per category as finalists. If there’s a tie for the last spot, include all tied games. Publish the finalists clearly, so everyone knows what they’re voting on.
  6. Run the final vote. Use a ranked-choice method (e.g., each voter ranks the finalists from 1 to 5) or a simple “pick one” vote. Ranked voting is fairer because it captures second choices. You can tally manually or use a free online ranked-choice voting tool.
  7. Announce the results. Reveal the winner in each category, and optionally share the full rankings and vote counts. This builds transparency and lets people see how close the race was.
  8. Celebrate and record. Make a small ceremony of it—maybe a virtual toast or a special game night featuring the winner. Keep a record of winners each year so you can look back and see how your group’s taste has evolved.

Common Mistakes

  • Not defining “this year” clearly. If you don’t specify whether it’s release year or first-played year, you’ll get arguments about whether a 2022 game counts.
  • Letting one person dominate nominations. Make sure everyone gets a say; otherwise, the result reflects one person’s preferences, not the group’s.
  • Including games only one person played. If only one member has played a game, it’s hard for others to vote fairly. Require that a game was played by at least two or three people to be eligible.
  • Overcomplicating the categories. Too many categories make voting tedious and dilute the meaning of “Game of the Year.” Stick to a few meaningful ones.
  • Rushing the timeline. Giving only a day for nominations or voting will leave people out. Give at least a few days for each phase.

Tips

  • Use a shared spreadsheet to track nominations and votes—it’s transparent and easy to update.
  • Encourage discussion before voting. Let people talk about why they loved a game. This can remind others of great moments and make the vote more informed.
  • Consider a “surprise” category for a game that exceeded expectations. It adds fun and often highlights hidden gems.
  • If you have a large group, use a poll tool that allows ranked voting. It saves time and reduces errors in tallying.
  • Make the announcement a mini-event. Even a short message with the results can feel special if you add a bit of fanfare.

Troubleshooting

What if nobody nominates anything? Start by suggesting a few games yourself, and ask specific people for their favorites. Sometimes people need a prompt. You can also set a deadline and remind everyone.

What if there’s a tie in the final vote? For a simple “pick one” vote, a tie means you need a tiebreaker. You can have a runoff between the tied games, or let the moderator decide (with group agreement). For ranked voting, ties are less common because you can use the number of first-place votes as a tiebreaker.

What if someone complains the process was unfair? Make sure you’ve published the rules and the vote counts. If a complaint is about eligibility, you can review the master list and adjust. The key is transparency—if everyone knows how the decision was made, most complaints fade.

What if a game wins that hardly anyone has played? This can happen if a few people are passionate about a niche game. To avoid this, set a minimum play count or require that at least half the group has played it. If it still wins, accept it—it’s what the voters wanted.

What if the group can’t agree on categories? Keep it simple: just have one “Game of the Year” category. You can always add more next year once everyone is comfortable with the process.

Frequently Asked Questions

How many categories should we have? Three to five is ideal. More than that and voting becomes a chore; fewer and you miss out on recognizing different types of games.

Should we include games that only some of us played? It depends on your group size. For a group of 4–6, it’s better to require that at least half the group has played a game to be eligible. For larger groups, a lower threshold might be okay.

What if a game was released this year but we didn’t play it until next year? That’s why it’s important to define “this year” as “first played this year” rather than “released this year.” That way, the game is eligible for the year you actually played it.

Can we include games we played online or remotely? Absolutely. If you played together, even over video chat, it counts. The goal is to celebrate the games you experienced as a group.

What if we can’t decide between a serious strategy game and a silly party game? That’s what categories are for. Have a “Best Strategy Game” and “Best Party Game” so both can win. The overall Game of the Year can still go to whichever the group loves most.

What if we want to do this again next year? Great! Keep a record of the rules and winners. At the start of the next year, review the process and tweak anything that didn’t work well. It’ll become a fun annual tradition.

Related

Method: the standard formula for this calculation, rounded as each result states. See how the calculators work or report an error.