ATS Integration Security Assessment Guide
This guide explains how to evaluate applicant tracking system (ATS) integrations for data security and candidate privacy. You will learn a practical, step-by-step process to review any integration—whether it is a resume parser, background check provider, or scheduling tool—before you connect it to your ATS. By following these steps, you can identify risks, ask the right questions, and make informed decisions that protect candidate data and your organization.
What You’ll Need
- Access to your ATS’s integration marketplace or API documentation
- A list of the specific integrations you plan to assess
- Your organization’s data protection and privacy policies
- Knowledge of relevant regulations (e.g., GDPR, CCPA) that apply to your candidate data
- A copy of the integration provider’s privacy policy and terms of service (or access to their website)
- A checklist or spreadsheet to record your findings
Step-by-Step
- Identify the data flow. For each integration, map out exactly what candidate data is sent, received, and stored. Check the ATS integration settings to see which fields are synced (e.g., name, email, resume, interview notes). Note whether the integration sends data one-way or two-way, and whether it accesses data in real time or via batch processing.
- Review the integration provider’s security documentation. Look for a security page, trust center, or compliance certifications (e.g., SOC 2, ISO 27001). Verify that the provider encrypts data in transit (using TLS) and at rest. If the documentation is missing or vague, treat that as a red flag.
- Check the provider’s privacy policy and data processing agreement. Confirm that the provider acts as a data processor on your behalf, not as a controller. Look for clauses about data retention, deletion, and sub-processors. Ensure the policy explains how candidate data is used and whether it is ever sold or shared with third parties for advertising.
- Assess access controls and authentication. Determine how the integration authenticates with your ATS (e.g., API keys, OAuth). Verify that the integration supports least-privilege access—meaning it only requests the permissions it needs. Avoid integrations that require admin-level access when a more limited scope is possible.
- Evaluate data minimization. Check whether the integration requests more data than necessary. For example, a scheduling tool should not need a candidate’s social security number. If the integration asks for excessive data, either configure it to limit fields or reconsider the integration.
- Review the vendor’s breach response and incident history. Search for any public disclosures of security incidents involving the provider. Ask the vendor for their incident response plan and how they would notify you in the event of a data breach. If they are unwilling to provide this, that is a major concern.
- Test the integration in a sandbox environment. Before going live, use a test environment to observe what data is transmitted. Use dummy candidate profiles to see exactly which fields are shared. This hands-on check often reveals surprises that documentation misses.
- Check for data retention and deletion capabilities. Verify that the integration allows you to delete candidate data when requested (e.g., a candidate asks for erasure under GDPR). Confirm that the vendor deletes data after a defined period and that you can manually trigger deletion.
- Review the sub-processor list. Many integrations rely on third-party services (e.g., cloud hosting, analytics). Ask the vendor for a list of sub-processors and check whether they have the same security standards. Ensure you can be notified of changes to this list.
- Document your findings and get approval. Record your assessment for each integration. If any red flags appear, either request remediation from the vendor or reject the integration. Obtain sign-off from your security or legal team before proceeding.
Common Mistakes
- Skipping the data flow map. Without knowing exactly what data is shared, you cannot assess risk. Many integrations have hidden fields that sync automatically.
- Trusting marketing claims. A vendor may claim to be “GDPR compliant” or “secure” without providing evidence. Always ask for certifications and documentation.
- Ignoring sub-processors. The integration provider may use a cloud provider that stores data in a different jurisdiction, which could violate your data residency requirements.
- Not testing in a sandbox. Documentation often understates the data that is actually transmitted. A live test with dummy data is essential.
- Overlooking data retention. If the integration stores candidate data indefinitely, you may be violating privacy regulations. Always check retention policies.
Tips
- Create a standardized scoring rubric (e.g., 1-5) for each security criterion so you can compare integrations objectively.
- Ask the vendor for their most recent SOC 2 Type II report or ISO 27001 certificate. These are audited and more reliable than self-assessments.
- Look for integrations that offer field-level configuration, so you can limit what data is shared.
- Check whether the integration supports single sign-on (SSO) for your users, which simplifies access control.
- Set a calendar reminder to re-assess critical integrations annually, as vendor security postures can change.
Troubleshooting
If the vendor does not provide security documentation: This is a major red flag. Politely insist on receiving at least a security overview and a data processing agreement. If they refuse, do not proceed with the integration.
If the integration requests more permissions than needed: Check if your ATS allows you to restrict the integration’s access. If not, contact the vendor to see if they offer a more limited scope. If they do not, consider an alternative integration.
If you discover a data breach after integration: Immediately revoke the integration’s access, notify your security team, and follow your incident response plan. Also, inform affected candidates if required by law.
If the integration fails to delete data on request: Document the failure, escalate to the vendor, and if unresolved, consider terminating the integration to avoid legal liability.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: What is the most important security feature to look for in an ATS integration?
A: End-to-end encryption (in transit and at rest) and strong access controls (like OAuth with least privilege) are the most critical. Without these, candidate data is exposed to interception and unauthorized access.
Q: Do I need to worry about GDPR if my company is based in the US?
A: Yes, if you collect data from EU residents. GDPR applies to any organization that processes the personal data of individuals in the EU, regardless of where the company is located. Always assess integrations with GDPR in mind.
Q: Can I rely on the ATS vendor’s security assessment of the integration?
A: No. The ATS vendor may not have thoroughly vetted every integration. You should conduct your own assessment, especially for integrations that handle sensitive data like resumes or background checks.
Q: How often should I re-assess my ATS integrations?
A: At least annually, or whenever there is a significant change to the integration (e.g., new features, change in sub-processors, or a security incident).
Q: What should I do if a candidate asks to delete their data from an integration?
A: You must be able to delete the data from the integration. If the integration does not support deletion, you may need to manually remove the data or terminate the integration for that candidate’s record. Ensure your data processing agreement includes a deletion clause.
Q: Is it safe to use free ATS integrations?
A: Not necessarily. Free integrations may have weaker security controls or monetize data in ways that violate privacy. Always assess them with the same rigor as paid integrations.
Related
Method: the standard formula for this calculation, rounded as each result states. See how the calculators work or report an error.