Has Metallic Hydrogen Been Made? Evidence Reviewed
Metallic hydrogen — hydrogen compressed until its electrons break free and flow like a metal — has been reported in the laboratory, but the evidence is not universally accepted. As of now, no independent team has reproduced the claim, so the honest answer is: possibly, but not confirmed.
What Is Metallic Hydrogen?
Hydrogen is the simplest element: one proton and one electron. On Earth it is a gas, but on giant planets like Jupiter and Saturn, the pressure deep inside is so extreme that hydrogen’s electron is squeezed away from its proton. When that happens, the material behaves like a metal — it conducts electricity and reflects light. This state is called metallic hydrogen, and it was first predicted in 1935 by physicists Eugene Wigner and Hillard Bell Huntington.
The prediction was straightforward: at a pressure of about 25 gigapascals (250,000 times Earth’s atmospheric pressure), hydrogen should become metallic. However, later calculations suggested the actual pressure needed is far higher — around 400–500 GPa, which is 4 to 5 million times atmospheric pressure. That is why it took decades to attempt in a lab.
Why Is It So Hard to Make?
To reach those pressures, scientists use a diamond anvil cell — two diamonds that squeeze a tiny sample between their flattened tips. The technique works, but there are serious problems:
- Diamonds crack — at several hundred GPa, even the hardest natural material fails.
- Hydrogen escapes — the tiny sample can leak or react with the diamond.
- Measurement is tricky — you need to prove the hydrogen is actually metallic, not just very dense.
Hydrogen also becomes solid at high pressure, so the sample is a solid crystal, not a liquid. That makes it harder to test for conductivity, because you need to attach electrodes to a sample that is only a few micrometers across.
The 2017 Harvard Claim
In January 2017, a team at Harvard University led by Isaac Silvera and Ranga Dias announced they had created metallic hydrogen. They reported compressing hydrogen at a pressure of 495 GPa (nearly 5 million atmospheres) and observing it become reflective — a sign of metallization. The result was published in the journal Science.
The team described the sample as shiny, like a metal, and said it remained solid at low temperature. They also claimed it was metastable, meaning it might stay metallic even after pressure is released — a property that could make it a revolutionary rocket fuel or superconductor.
Why the Evidence Is Disputed
Other researchers immediately raised doubts. The main issues were:
- No independent replication — no other lab has reproduced the exact result.
- Possible diamond contamination — a thin layer of diamond from the anvil could have reflected light, giving a false signal.
- Pressure calibration — the pressure measurement at 495 GPa was based on the diamond’s Raman shift, which is not fully reliable at that extreme.
- Lost sample — the Harvard team said the sample was lost during a later attempt to measure its electrical conductivity, so the key proof (conductivity) was never obtained.
In 2018, the same team reported a second experiment, but again without independent confirmation. As of 2024, no other group has published a successful replication.
What Would Prove It?
To convincingly show metallic hydrogen, a lab would need to measure both:
- Electrical conductivity — the sample must conduct electricity like a metal.
- Optical reflectivity — it should reflect light across a broad spectrum, not just at one wavelength.
Ideally, both measurements would be made on the same sample, and the experiment would be repeated by an independent group. So far, no one has done that.
What Would Metallic Hydrogen Be Used For?
If it exists and is metastable, metallic hydrogen could be:
- A rocket propellant — it would release enormous energy when it recombines to form molecular hydrogen.
- A room-temperature superconductor — theoretical models suggest it could conduct electricity with zero resistance at room temperature, which would revolutionise power grids and electronics.
- A tool for planetary science — understanding its properties helps explain the magnetic fields of Jupiter and Saturn, which are generated by metallic hydrogen deep inside those planets.
Where Does the Search Stand Now?
Research continues, but progress is slow because of the extreme difficulty of the experiment. Some groups are trying alternative methods, such as dynamic compression using lasers, but those produce only transient states. Others are using theoretical models to predict exactly what pressure and temperature are needed.
In 2020, a team in France reported evidence of a phase transition in hydrogen at around 460 GPa, but they did not claim to have made metallic hydrogen. The search is still open.
Frequently Asked Questions
Has metallic hydrogen been made?
Not confirmed. The Harvard team claimed success in 2017, but no independent lab has reproduced it, and the evidence (reflectivity) was not backed by conductivity measurements.
Why is metallic hydrogen important?
It could be a room-temperature superconductor and a powerful rocket fuel, and it helps explain the interiors of gas giant planets.
How much pressure is needed?
About 400–500 GPa, which is 4 to 5 million times Earth’s atmospheric pressure. That’s higher than the pressure at the center of Earth.
Is metallic hydrogen stable at room temperature?
It is predicted to be metastable, meaning it might remain metallic even after pressure is released, but this has not been proven.
Could metallic hydrogen be used as a fuel?
In theory, yes. When it reverts to normal hydrogen, it releases a huge amount of energy, making it an extremely dense rocket propellant. But no one has made enough to test it.
Why don’t we just make it in a larger machine?
Because the pressure needed is so high that no large-scale device can sustain it. Diamond anvil cells are the only way to reach those pressures, and they only work on microscopic samples.
Related
Method: the standard formula for this calculation, rounded as each result states. See how the calculators work or report an error.