ThisCalculator

Everyday

Forgotten Game of the Year Winners: 7 That Faded Fast

Updated · Standard formula, shown below

Average pace 5.00 min/km
Average speed
12.00 km/h
Result
Finish time
50 min
You entered
Distance
10 km
You entered

Some Game of the Year winners are remembered for decades, but others fade from conversation almost immediately. This article looks at seven former GOTY winners that seem to have been quickly forgotten, and explains why they slipped out of the spotlight despite their critical acclaim.

What Makes a GOTY Winner Memorable?

Winning Game of the Year is a huge honor, but it doesn’t guarantee lasting fame. Some winners become cultural touchstones (think Breath of the Wild or God of War), while others are barely mentioned a few years later. The difference usually comes down to a few factors:

  • Cultural impact: Did the game introduce a meme, a mechanic, or a story that people still talk about?
  • Sequels and remasters: A sequel can keep the original in the public eye, or a remaster can revive it. Without either, the original may be forgotten.
  • Online community: Games with active multiplayer or modding communities stay alive longer.
  • Timing: A game released late in a year may win awards but get overshadowed by the next year’s big releases.
  • Platform exclusivity: Exclusives on less popular platforms (like Wii U) are seen by fewer people, which limits their long-term footprint.

7 Former Winners That Faded Fast

Here are seven notable GOTY winners that, despite their awards, are rarely mentioned today. These are based on major award shows (like The Game Awards, BAFTA, D.I.C.E., and GDC) and major publication awards (like IGN, GameSpot, and Edge).

  1. Dragon Age: Inquisition (2014) – Won Game of the Year at The Game Awards, D.I.C.E., and BAFTA. It was a massive RPG with a strong single-player campaign, but its live-service multiplayer and the divisive ending led to a quick fade. The next game, Dragon Age: The Veilguard, took a decade to arrive, and by then many players had moved on.
  2. Overwatch (2016) – Won GOTY at The Game Awards and D.I.C.E. It was a cultural phenomenon with a huge esports scene, but the game’s sequel (released in 2022) replaced it, and the original was eventually shut down. The franchise’s reputation also suffered from content droughts and controversy, so the original’s legacy is now mostly nostalgia.
  3. It Takes Two (2021) – Won GOTY at The Game Awards and BAFTA. It’s a brilliant co-op game, but it’s a one-time experience. Once you finish it, there’s little reason to return. Its developer, Hazelight Studios, has moved on to a new project, and the game is rarely discussed outside of “best co-op games” lists.
  4. Uncharted 4: A Thief’s End (2016) – Won GOTY at BAFTA and several critic awards. It was a fantastic conclusion to Nathan Drake’s story, but it was also the end. Without a sequel or a major multiplayer scene, it faded quickly. The Uncharted movie (2022) brought some attention back, but the game itself is not a frequent topic of conversation.
  5. Persona 5 (2017) – Won GOTY at several outlets, including GameSpot and EGM. It’s a beloved JRPG, but it’s also a 100-hour game that many people never finished. The enhanced re-release Persona 5 Royal (2020) is now the definitive version, and it’s that version that gets talked about, not the original.
  6. Baldur’s Gate 3 (2023) – This one is still fresh, but it’s already showing signs of fading from the mainstream conversation. It won GOTY at The Game Awards and D.I.C.E., but it’s a niche CRPG that requires a huge time investment. Its massive success may be a one-time phenomenon, and it’s unclear if it will have the lasting cultural impact of, say, Skyrim.
  7. The Last of Us Part II (2020) – Won GOTY at The Game Awards, D.I.C.E., and BAFTA. It was a critical darling with a polarizing story. The controversy around its narrative overshadowed its technical and artistic achievements, and the game’s reputation remains divisive. The HBO series (2023) helped keep the franchise alive, but the game itself is often discussed in terms of its plot, not as a beloved classic.

Why Do Some Winners Fade?

There’s no single reason, but a few patterns emerge:

  • No lasting multiplayer: Games like Uncharted 4 and It Takes Two are single-player experiences. Once you’re done, you’re done. Multiplayer games like Overwatch can stay relevant for years, but they also risk being replaced by sequels.
  • Sequels that outshine the original: Persona 5 Royal is better than the original, so people play that instead. Overwatch 2 replaced the original entirely.
  • Controversy and backlash: The Last of Us Part II was a lightning rod for debate. That controversy kept it in the news for a while, but it also made it hard to discuss without reopening old wounds.
  • Genre niche: Baldur’s Gate 3 is a CRPG, a genre that’s not for everyone. Even with its mainstream success, it doesn’t have the broad appeal of an action-adventure or shooter.
  • Timing and competition: A game that wins in a year with many other iconic releases (like 2017’s Breath of the Wild vs. Persona 5) may get overshadowed by the bigger winner.

How to Choose a GOTY Winner Worth Playing Today

If you’re looking back at old winners, you don’t have to pick the most famous one. Here’s how to decide which one is worth your time now:

  • Check the genre: Do you like turn-based RPGs? Then Persona 5 might be for you. Prefer action-adventure? Try Uncharted 4.
  • Look for the “definitive” version: Many GOTY winners have enhanced re-releases. For Persona 5, play Royal. For The Last of Us Part II, the PS5 remaster is the best way to play.
  • Consider the time commitment: Baldur’s Gate 3 can take 100+ hours. It Takes Two is about 10 hours. Pick based on your schedule.
  • Think about co-op: If you have a partner or friend, It Takes Two is a must. If you’re solo, skip it.
  • Read recent reviews: A game that won GOTY in 2014 may not have aged well. Check current reviews to see if it holds up.

Common Mistakes When Revisiting Old Winners

When you go back to a GOTY winner from years ago, you might be disappointed. Here are some common pitfalls:

  • Expecting modern graphics: Dragon Age: Inquisition looks dated. That’s fine – the story and gameplay are what matter.
  • Comparing to current games: Overwatch (2016) feels slower and simpler than Overwatch 2. Don’t expect a 2024 experience.
  • Ignoring the context: Uncharted 4 was a technical marvel in 2016, but today it’s just a good-looking game. Its strengths are the story and characters.
  • Playing the wrong version: If you play the original Persona 5 instead of Royal, you’ll miss out on quality-of-life improvements and extra content.
  • Not checking for remasters: Some games have been remastered for newer consoles, which is the best way to play them. Always check if a remaster exists.

Comparisons: Why Some Winners Are Remembered and Others Aren’t

Let’s compare a few pairs to see why one is remembered and the other isn’t:

  • Breath of the Wild vs. Persona 5 (both 2017): Breath of the Wild changed open-world design and is still referenced in every new open-world game. Persona 5 is a great JRPG, but it didn’t change the industry. Its legacy is more niche.
  • God of War (2018) vs. Dragon Age: Inquisition (2014): God of War had a cinematic, intimate story that stuck with players. Dragon Age had a sprawling world but a generic villain and a weak ending. The former is a classic, the latter is a footnote.
  • Overwatch vs. Fortnite (not a GOTY winner, but a comparison): Overwatch won GOTY, but Fortnite became a cultural phenomenon. Why? Fortnite was free-to-play and had constant updates, while Overwatch was paid and had slower content drops.

The Role of Awards in a Game’s Legacy

Winning GOTY doesn’t guarantee immortality. Awards are a snapshot of a moment in time – they reflect the tastes of critics and the industry at that moment. A game can win because it’s innovative, polished, or just the best in a weak year. But legacy is built by players, not awards. If players don’t keep playing a game, talking about it, or modding it, it will fade, no matter how many trophies it has.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why do some GOTY winners get forgotten?

Usually because they lack a lasting multiplayer community, have a sequel that replaces them, or are in a niche genre. Controversy can also make people avoid discussing them.

Are there any GOTY winners that were actually bad?

“Bad” is subjective, but some winners have aged poorly. Dragon Age: Inquisition is often criticized for its fetch-quests, and Overwatch’s reputation has been hurt by its sequel’s issues. However, they were all well-received at launch.

What is the most forgotten GOTY winner of all time?

It’s hard to say, but Dragon Age: Inquisition is a strong candidate. It won many awards but is rarely mentioned today, and even its own studio seemed to distance itself from it for years.

Should I play a forgotten GOTY winner or a more famous one?

It depends on your taste. If you want a game that’s still discussed and has a community, pick a famous one like God of War or Breath of the Wild. If you want something different and don’t mind a dated experience, try a forgotten one like Dragon Age or Uncharted 4.

Do GOTY winners get remasters?

Some do. Persona 5 got Royal, The Last of Us Part II got a PS5 remaster, and Uncharted 4 got a PS5 remaster as part of the Legacy of Thieves Collection. Others, like Overwatch, were replaced by sequels instead.

Which GOTY winner is most likely to be forgotten in the future?

Baldur’s Gate 3 could be forgotten if its studio doesn’t follow up with a sequel or if the CRPG genre remains niche. But it’s too early to tell – it might also become a classic like Skyrim.

Related

Formula used
in t | Finish time | min | 50 | 0
in d | Distance | km | 10 | 0
out pace | Average pace | min/km | t / d | 2
out speed | Average speed | km/h | d / (t / 60) | 2

Each line is one input (in, sel, list) or one result (out: label, unit, formula, decimals). How the calculators work

Method: the standard formula for this calculation, rounded as each result states. See how the calculators work or report an error.