ThisCalculator

Everyday

Direct Play vs Transcoding: NAS Needs for Plex & Jellyfin

Updated · Standard formula, shown below

Direct play means your NAS sends the original file to the client without any conversion, while transcoding converts the video or audio on the fly to match the player’s capabilities. For most home users, a NAS that can handle at least one or two 1080p transcodes is enough, but if you want 4K HDR transcoding, you need a model with a modern Intel CPU with Quick Sync or a dedicated GPU.

What Direct Play and Transcoding Actually Mean

When you stream a movie, the server (your NAS) and the client (TV, phone, browser) negotiate what formats the client can handle. Direct play happens when the file’s video codec (like H.264 or HEVC), audio codec (like AAC or AC3), and container (like MKV or MP4) are all supported by the client. The NAS simply reads the file and sends it over the network, using almost no CPU power.

Transcoding is needed when the client can’t play the original file. The server decodes the video, changes it (for example, from HEVC to H.264, or from 4K to 1080p), and re-encodes it in real time. This is CPU-intensive, and for 4K HDR content, it can also involve tone mapping to convert HDR to SDR, which is even more demanding.

Why Transcoding Happens (and When It Doesn’t)

Common reasons a file gets transcoded:

  • The client’s screen resolution is lower than the file (e.g., 4K file on a 1080p TV).
  • The audio format isn’t supported (e.g., TrueHD or DTS on a device that only decodes AAC).
  • Subtitles are burned in (image-based subtitles like PGS often force video transcoding).
  • The network bandwidth is limited, so the server reduces the bitrate.
  • The client’s browser or app lacks support for the container (e.g., MKV on some smart TVs).

Direct play avoids all this. It also preserves the original quality and uses almost no NAS resources, so multiple users can stream simultaneously without any performance hit.

What Your NAS Needs for Direct Play

For direct play, the NAS just needs to read the file and push it over the network. A basic two-bay NAS with an ARM processor can handle several direct play streams, as long as the network and disk speed are sufficient. The bottleneck is usually the network: a 1 Gbps connection can handle roughly 8-10 concurrent 1080p streams at 10-12 Mbps each, or one 4K stream at 40-50 Mbps.

So, if you only ever direct play, you don’t need a powerful NAS. Even an entry-level model like a Synology DS220j or a QNAP TS-230 will work fine for a handful of users. The key is to ensure your clients are set to “Original” quality in Plex or Jellyfin, and that your network is wired or has good Wi-Fi.

What Your NAS Needs for Transcoding

Transcoding is where hardware matters. The CPU does the heavy lifting, and not all NAS processors are equal. Here’s a rough breakdown:

  • ARM processors (e.g., Realtek RTD1296): Can handle one 1080p transcode at best, often struggle with 4K. Not recommended for heavy transcoding.
  • Intel Celeron J4125 or J4025: With Quick Sync (Intel’s hardware video encoder), these can handle 2-4 concurrent 1080p transcodes, and even one 4K transcode if tone mapping is not required.
  • Intel Core i3 or i5 (e.g., in QNAP or Synology plus models): Can handle 4-6+ 1080p transcodes, and 1-2 4K transcodes with tone mapping.
  • AMD Ryzen (no iGPU on most): Without an iGPU, transcoding is done on the CPU, which is slower and uses more power. Not ideal for Plex/Jellyfin.

If you have 4K HDR content and any client that can’t direct play it (like a browser or an older TV), you’ll need a NAS with Intel Quick Sync (7th gen or newer) to handle tone mapping efficiently. Otherwise, the transcode will fail or use 100% CPU.

How Plex and Jellyfin Differ

Plex and Jellyfin both support hardware transcoding, but there are differences:

  • Plex: Hardware transcoding requires a Plex Pass subscription (one-time or monthly). Without it, you only get software transcoding, which is much slower. Plex also has a proprietary “Plex Media Server” that is polished but closed-source.
  • Jellyfin: Free and open-source, with hardware acceleration built-in for Intel Quick Sync, AMD, and NVIDIA GPUs. It’s a bit less polished but offers more control and no cost. Jellyfin’s tone mapping is also free, while Plex’s is part of the subscription.

Both work well on the same NAS hardware. The choice often comes down to whether you want the simplicity of Plex (with its apps and metadata) or the freedom of Jellyfin (no account required, fully self-hosted).

Choosing the Right NAS for Your Use Case

Here’s a practical guide based on what you plan to do:

  1. Only direct play on home network: Any NAS with at least 1GB RAM and a gigabit LAN port. Even an ARM-based model works.
  2. Occasional transcoding (1-2 users, 1080p): Look for a NAS with an Intel Celeron J4125 or better. Models like Synology DS423+ or QNAP TS-464 are good examples.
  3. 4K HDR transcoding or multiple users: Get a NAS with an Intel Core i3 or i5, or one that supports adding a GPU. Some QNAP models have PCIe slots for a graphics card. Alternatively, you can run a separate mini-PC with an Intel NUC as your media server.
  4. Budget option: If you already have a PC, you can install Plex or Jellyfin on it and use the NAS just for storage. This offloads transcoding to the PC.

Remember that RAM is also important: 2GB is fine for direct play, but 4-8GB is recommended for transcoding, especially with 4K.

Common Problems and How to Avoid Them

Even with a capable NAS, you might run into issues:

  • Transcoding stutters: Check if hardware acceleration is enabled in Plex/Jellyfin settings. In Plex, you need Plex Pass. In Jellyfin, you need to enable the correct hardware decoder in the admin dashboard.
  • 4K HDR looks washed out: This happens when tone mapping is not enabled. In Plex, enable “Enable HDR tone mapping” under Transcoder settings. In Jellyfin, it’s under Playback > Transcoding.
  • Subtitles force transcoding: If you use image-based subtitles (like PGS), try converting them to text-based (SRT) using tools like MKVToolNix, or burn them into the video if you don’t need to switch them.
  • Audio transcodes even when video direct plays: This is common with TrueHD or DTS audio on devices that don’t support them. You can set the client to use a compatible audio track (like AC3) or let the server transcode audio only, which is less CPU-heavy.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can a Raspberry Pi handle Plex/Jellyfin?

A Raspberry Pi 4 or 5 can direct play most content, but it will struggle with 1080p transcoding and cannot handle 4K transcoding. It’s fine for a single user who uses compatible clients, but not for a family with mixed devices.

Does transcoding reduce quality?

Yes, transcoding re-encodes the video, which can reduce quality, especially if you lower the bitrate. Direct play preserves the original quality. For best quality, always try to direct play.

Is hardware transcoding worth it?

Yes, if you transcode regularly. Hardware transcoding is many times faster and uses far less power than software transcoding. It also allows multiple simultaneous transcodes. For Plex, it requires a paid subscription, but for Jellyfin it’s free.

What is the minimum NAS for 4K transcoding?

You need a NAS with an Intel CPU that has Quick Sync (7th gen or newer) and at least 4GB RAM. Examples include Synology DS920+ (Celeron J4125) or QNAP TS-453D (J4125). Even then, only one 4K transcode is realistic. For multiple 4K transcodes, you’d need a more powerful CPU or a GPU.

Should I use a NAS or a mini-PC for Plex/Jellyfin?

If you already have a NAS, use it. If you’re buying new, a mini-PC with an Intel N100 or better can be cheaper and more powerful for transcoding, but you’ll lose the storage expansion that a NAS offers. Many people use a NAS for storage and a mini-PC for the media server.

Does Jellyfin support hardware transcoding on AMD GPUs?

Yes, Jellyfin supports AMD GPUs via VA-API, but the support is less mature than Intel Quick Sync. For best compatibility, Intel or NVIDIA are safer choices.

Related

Method: the standard formula for this calculation, rounded as each result states. See how the calculators work or report an error.