Delete Digital Footprint Incogni: Does It Work?
- Incogni annual cost
- $
- Result
- Savings with Incogni
- $
- Result
- Time spent (minutes)
- 30 min
- You entered
Incogni is a data removal service that sends legal requests on your behalf to data brokers and people-search sites, and it can help shrink your digital footprint, but it cannot delete everything about you online. You still need to manually remove accounts, social media posts, and other content you created yourself. This article explains how Incogni works, what it can and cannot do, and how it compares to doing the work yourself.
Formula
The calculator estimates the cost of removing your personal data from data brokers yourself, compared to using Incogni for a year.
- Cost of DIY removal = (Time spent per broker in minutes ÷ 60) × Hourly rate × Number of brokers
- Incogni annual cost = $84 (current annual subscription price)
- Savings with Incogni = Cost of DIY removal − Incogni annual cost
Variables: t = minutes spent per broker, r = your hourly rate (opportunity cost), d = number of brokers you target.
Worked Example
Using the default values: t = 30 minutes, r = $25/hour, d = 40 brokers.
- Convert minutes to hours: 30 ÷ 60 = 0.5 hours per broker.
- Multiply by hourly rate: 0.5 × 25 = $12.50 per broker.
- Multiply by number of brokers: 12.50 × 40 = $500.
- So DIY cost = $500. Incogni costs $84/year. Savings = $500 − $84 = $416.
This shows that if your time is worth $25/hour, using Incogni can save you over $400 per year compared to doing it manually, assuming you would actually spend that time.
What Is Incogni and How Does It Work?
Incogni is a subscription service launched in 2022 by Surfshark, a VPN company. It automates the process of sending privacy requests under laws like the California Consumer Privacy Act (CCPA) and the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) to data brokers and people-search sites. The service targets companies that collect and sell your personal information—like your name, address, phone number, and email—often without your explicit consent.
When you sign up, you provide your email address and basic details. Incogni then scans its database of known data brokers, finds which ones have your information, and sends opt-out requests on your behalf. It tracks the progress and resubmits requests if a broker ignores or rejects them. The service claims to cover over 100 data brokers, but the exact number varies over time.
What Does “Digital Footprint” Actually Include?
Your digital footprint is all the traces you leave online. It includes:
- Active data: social media posts, comments, photos, and account profiles you create.
- Passive data: cookies, IP addresses, browsing history, and location data collected by websites.
- Broker data: information aggregated by data brokers from public records, surveys, and purchases—this is what Incogni targets.
- Public records: property ownership, court records, voter registration, and business filings.
Incogni only addresses the broker data category. It cannot delete your social media accounts, remove your comments from forums, or erase public records. Those require separate actions from you.
How to Choose Between Incogni and DIY Removal
Deciding whether to use Incogni or do it yourself depends on your time, budget, and privacy needs. Consider these factors:
- Time: Manual removal from 40 brokers could take 20+ hours of work. If you value your time at more than $4/hour, Incogni is likely cheaper.
- Persistence: Brokers often ignore or reject first requests. Incogni resubmits automatically; you would need to track and follow up manually.
- Coverage: Incogni has a list of brokers it contacts. DIY allows you to target any broker you find, but you must discover them yourself.
- Cost: Incogni costs about $7/month (billed annually). DIY is free in money, but costs time.
- Control: DIY gives you full control over what you submit and to whom. Incogni handles it but you must trust the service with your data.
Common Problems and Limitations
Incogni is not a magic erase button. Users report several limitations:
- Reappearing data: Brokers may re-add your information after a few months, requiring ongoing requests. Incogni runs continuously, but you may still see your data reappear.
- Not all brokers covered: Incogni’s list is not exhaustive. Small local brokers or niche sites may not be included.
- Public records: Court records and property records are often exempt from deletion. Incogni cannot remove these.
- Data you posted: Incogni does not touch your own social media posts or comments. You must delete those manually.
- Email and phone: Incogni asks for your email to operate, which ironically adds your email to its own database. It does not remove your email from all lists.
Comparison: Incogni vs. Other Services and DIY
Incogni is one of several data removal services. Others include DeleteMe, PrivacyBee, and Kanary. Here’s a quick comparison:
- Incogni: $84/year, automated, covers 100+ brokers, good for budget-conscious users.
- DeleteMe: ~$129/year, longer track record, provides detailed reports, more expensive.
- PrivacyBee: ~$199/year, focuses on small businesses and individuals, offers manual assistance.
- DIY: Free, but time-consuming and requires persistence. You can use guides like those from the Privacy Rights Clearinghouse to find opt-out links.
Incogni is generally cheaper than competitors, but it may have a shorter track record. For most people, the main trade-off is cost vs. time.
Is Incogni Safe and Legal?
Incogni operates legally by using rights granted under CCPA, GDPR, and similar laws. It does not hack into databases or use deceptive tactics. The service is owned by Surfshark, a reputable VPN provider, and it encrypts your data in transit. However, you are giving Incogni your personal information (name, email, address) to send requests. This is necessary, but you should read their privacy policy to understand how they handle your data. They claim not to sell your data, and they are bound by GDPR if you are in the EU.
One concern: Incogni cannot verify that brokers actually delete your data. It relies on the brokers’ compliance. Some brokers may ignore requests, and Incogni’s resubmission process may not be enough. Also, if you live outside the US/EU, the legal basis for requests may be weaker, so effectiveness varies by country.
Alternatives to Incogni
If you don’t want to pay or want more control, here are alternatives:
- Manual opt-out: Use resources like the Privacy Rights Clearinghouse’s data broker list to find opt-out links. Set aside an hour per week to submit requests.
- Use a dedicated email: Create a separate email for sign-ups to reduce spam and tracking.
- Browser privacy tools: Use ad blockers and privacy extensions like uBlock Origin or Privacy Badger to reduce passive tracking.
- Contact brokers directly: Some brokers have simple opt-out forms. Focus on the ones that appear in search results for your name.
- Remove yourself from people-search sites: Sites like Whitepages, Spokeo, and BeenVerified have opt-out pages. Do these first.
Remember, no service can guarantee complete deletion. Your digital footprint is like an iceberg—you only see the tip, but much is underwater.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does Incogni really delete my data?
Incogni sends requests, but it cannot force brokers to comply. Most brokers do remove your data after a valid request, but some may re-add it later. Incogni resubmits periodically, but you should check search results for your name after a few months to see if you’re still listed.
How long does Incogni take to show results?
Typically, you’ll see some removals within 2–4 weeks, but it can take up to 3 months for full coverage. Brokers have varying response times, and some require multiple requests. Incogni’s dashboard shows progress, but you may need to be patient.
Can Incogni remove my social media accounts?
No. Incogni only handles data broker listings. Social media accounts, posts, and comments are yours to manage. You must delete them manually through each platform’s settings.
Is Incogni worth the money for most people?
If your time is valuable and you’re concerned about your data being sold, yes. The calculator above shows that DIY removal can cost more in time than the subscription. But if you have more time than money, or you only appear on a few sites, doing it yourself may be sufficient.
Will Incogni stop spam emails and robocalls?
Not directly. Removing your data from brokers may reduce some targeted spam, but it won’t stop all spam or robocalls. You still need to use email filters and call-blocking apps. Incogni focuses on data broker listings, not direct marketing lists.
What happens if I cancel Incogni?
If you cancel, Incogni stops sending new requests. Data that was removed may reappear over time as brokers re-add it. You can always re-subscribe later, but you’ll have to start the process again.
Related
Formula used
in t | Time spent (minutes) | min | 30 | 0 in r | Hourly rate ($) | $ | 25 | 0 in d | Number of data brokers | - | 40 | 1 out cost | Cost of DIY removal | $ | (t/60) * r * d | 2 out incogni | Incogni annual cost | $ | 84 | 2 out savings | Savings with Incogni | $ | cost - incogni | 2
Each line is one input (in, sel, list) or one result (out: label, unit, formula, decimals). How the calculators work
Method: the standard formula for this calculation, rounded as each result states. See how the calculators work or report an error.