Cosmic Desktop: Incredible but Not Ready?
Cosmic Desktop is a new Linux desktop environment that looks impressive, but it is not yet ready for most users as a daily driver. This article explains what Cosmic is, how it works, what works well, what is missing, and who should consider using it now.
What Is Cosmic Desktop?
Cosmic is a desktop environment developed by System76, the company known for its Linux laptops and the Pop!_OS distribution. It is written in Rust, a programming language focused on safety and performance, and it is designed to be a modern, flexible, and visually polished alternative to GNOME, KDE Plasma, and other Linux desktops. The project started because System76 wanted more control over the user experience on its own hardware, and it has grown into a full desktop environment that is being developed in the open.
The name “Cosmic” is not an acronym; it is a reference to the idea of a vast, cohesive system. The desktop is built around a compositor called COSMIC, which is based on the Wayland display protocol rather than the older X11. Wayland is the modern standard for Linux graphics, offering better security and smoother rendering, but it also means that some older applications that rely on X11 features may not work perfectly.
How Cosmic Differs from Other Desktops
Most Linux desktops are built on years of accumulated code, often mixing different toolkits and design languages. Cosmic is a ground-up rewrite, which gives it several unique characteristics:
- Rust-based: The entire desktop, including the compositor and shell, is written in Rust. This makes it less prone to memory errors and crashes compared to C or C++ based desktops.
- Wayland-native: Cosmic uses Wayland exclusively, with no fallback to X11. This means it is designed for modern graphics from the start, but it also means that X11-only applications will need a compatibility layer like XWayland.
- Tiling and floating: Cosmic includes a built-in tiling window manager, similar to what you find in i3 or Sway, but it also supports traditional floating windows. You can switch between modes or use them together.
- Customizable workspace: The desktop has a workspace system that is both horizontal and vertical, allowing you to arrange windows in a grid. This is different from the linear workspace switchers in GNOME or KDE.
- No GNOME dependencies: Many desktops rely on GNOME libraries, but Cosmic is independent. This means it does not inherit GNOME’s design decisions or its occasional instability.
What Works Well Right Now
Even in its early stages, Cosmic has several features that are already polished and usable:
- Performance: Because it is written in Rust and uses Wayland, Cosmic feels very responsive. Animations are smooth, and the desktop uses less memory than GNOME or KDE in many cases.
- Built-in tiling: The tiling window manager is one of the best I have seen on Linux. It is easy to configure, supports keyboard shortcuts, and works well with multiple monitors.
- Appearance: The default theme is clean and modern, with a dark mode that is easy on the eyes. Icons and fonts are well-chosen, and the overall look is consistent.
- Settings app: The settings application is well-organized and covers most of what you need, from display configuration to keyboard shortcuts. It is more intuitive than GNOME’s settings, which often hide options behind extensions.
- Stability: For a pre-release desktop, Cosmic is surprisingly stable. I have used it for several days without a crash, and even the nightly builds are usable.
What Is Missing or Broken
Despite its strengths, Cosmic is not yet ready for everyone. Here are the main issues:
- Extension system: Cosmic does not have a mature extension system like GNOME. While it has some built-in customization, you cannot easily add third-party extensions to change behavior or add features.
- Missing applications: Some essential tools are not yet available, such as a built-in screen recorder, a clipboard manager, or a system monitor. You can install third-party apps, but they may not integrate perfectly.
- Wayland limitations: Some applications, especially older ones or those that rely on X11 features like screen sharing, may not work correctly. For example, some video conferencing tools have issues with screen sharing on Wayland.
- Fractional scaling: While fractional scaling is supported, it can be inconsistent on some hardware. Text may appear blurry in some applications, and performance can suffer.
- Bugs: There are still bugs, especially in less common configurations. For example, using multiple monitors with different resolutions can cause glitches, and some keyboard shortcuts may not work as expected.
Who Should Use Cosmic Now?
Cosmic is ideal for developers, early adopters, and Linux enthusiasts who want to test a new desktop and are comfortable with occasional bugs. It is also great for people who love tiling window managers and want a modern, integrated experience. However, if you rely on your computer for work, need specific applications that only work on X11, or are not comfortable troubleshooting, you should wait for the stable release.
System76 plans to make Cosmic the default desktop in Pop!_OS, but that is not expected until the desktop is more mature. In the meantime, you can try Cosmic on other distributions like Arch Linux or Fedora, but be prepared to spend time configuring it.
How to Try Cosmic
If you want to try Cosmic, the easiest way is to install Pop!_OS 24.04 LTS, which includes Cosmic as an option. You can also install it on other distributions, but the process is more involved. Here are the general steps:
- Back up your data, as installing a new desktop can sometimes cause issues.
- Install the Cosmic packages from your distribution’s repository. For example, on Arch, you can use the
cosmicpackage group. - Log out and select Cosmic from the login screen.
- If you encounter issues, check the Cosmic GitHub repository for known bugs and workarounds.
Remember that Cosmic is still in alpha, so you should not install it on a system you cannot afford to break.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Cosmic ready for daily use?
Not for most people. It is stable enough for basic tasks, but missing features and bugs make it risky for daily use. If you are a developer or enthusiast, you can try it, but have a backup plan.
Will Cosmic replace GNOME in Pop!_OS?
Yes, System76 has announced that Cosmic will be the default desktop in Pop!_OS after it is stable. However, there is no confirmed release date, and it may be several months away.
Can I use Cosmic on other Linux distributions?
Yes, Cosmic is available on several distributions, including Arch, Fedora, and openSUSE. However, the installation process varies, and you may need to compile some components.
Does Cosmic support Nvidia graphics?
Yes, Cosmic supports Nvidia graphics, but you may need to install the proprietary drivers. System76 has worked on Nvidia support, but there can still be issues with Wayland on some Nvidia GPUs.
What is the difference between Cosmic and KDE Plasma?
Cosmic is a new, Rust-based desktop with a focus on simplicity and performance, while KDE Plasma is a mature, feature-rich desktop with many options. Cosmic is more minimal, while KDE is more customizable out of the box.
Will my existing Linux applications work on Cosmic?
Most applications will work, but some that rely on X11 features may have issues. You can use XWayland to run X11 apps, but screen sharing and some other features may not work perfectly.
Related
Method: the standard formula for this calculation, rounded as each result states. See how the calculators work or report an error.